[QUOTE=Phantom Dennis]
3) the polygonal rifling in the bore adds a bit of extra muzzle velocity and accuracy compared to standard rifling in barrels of the same length. Polygonal rifling is becoming common in other brands though.
I’m not convinced that Glocks explode more often than other pistols. There are lots of rumors on the net, complete with photographs of blown-up Glocks, but in almost every case the detonation involves non-factory reloads, which frankly can cause any gun to explode. Some suggest that the polygonal rifling collects lead deposits more rapidly than standard rifling, so if you fire too many lead slugs through the barrel, eventually the gun’s going to plug itself up and turn into a hand grenade. Again, I think this is a reload problem. Factory pistol ammunition should be copper-jacketed – if you buy pistol rounds with unjacketed lead slugs, chances are it’s some kind of cheap reload, and you’d be taking a chance by firing it through any pistol. But if you insist on putting lead slugs through a Glock, you’re probably okay as long as you clean it semi-regularly.
Also, if a round explodes in the chamber of any plastic gun, you probably don’t have the same kind of protection you’d get from a gun with metal frame and slide. Again, this is probably a non-issue if you stick with factory ammo.
[/QUOTE]
Let’s address a couple of misconceptions:
First of all, referring to a Glock as a “plastic gun” offers the wrong image to someone not well-versed in material science. Glocks, and other polymer-framed handguns, are made from a reinforced polymer composite (typically some kind of e-glass fiber in a high strength polymer matrix). This has a tensile strength equal to or in excess of the popular aluminum-framed handguns and is less prone to cracking than either aluminum or steel frames. The Glock frame design has been noted as handling full power .45 Super, .400 Cor-Bon, and 10mm Auto loads that have caused failures in steel framed guns like the Colt Delta Elite and the S&W 1006. Polymer framed guns are somewhat lighter than aluminum frame pistols and definitely lighter than steel frame guns, to be sure, but the real advantage is their corrosion resistance–they simply don’t corrode and are resistant to normal solvents.
Second, there is an assemblege of people who, for whatever reason, have a vendetta against the Glock and perpetrate a number of misapprehenions and ill-founded claims about the propensity of this gun to misfire, slamfire, and explode. The gun has been torture tested by numerous law enforcement and military agencies that require the gun to maintain integrity with a blocked barrel and firing ammo that is well above SAAMI spec pressures. The barrel may bulge or split, but the notion that it will expode “like a grenade” is false. At worst (as happened with a number of pre-mod Beretta M9s in the sandy conditions during Gulf War I) the slide comes free somehow and ejects backward toward the shooter; a dangerous situation, to be sure, but nothing like a grenade exploding.
Third, while it is not common in autoloader calibers like the 9mm, you can purchase unjacked ball ammo. IIRC, Black Hills offers an unjacketed 124 grain 9mmP round, and of course hand loaded can cast and load unjacketed ammo for cost savings. Lead from unjacketed rounds can certainly foul polygonal rifling if the barrel isn’t cleaned with a lead-remover regularly, but I find it more likely that this would effect accuracy long before the gun would explode. In any case, poly rifled barrels are typically hammer-forged and are therefore considerably stronger than button reamed barrels. Lead deposit is a noted problem with gas-operated firearms like the gas-retared delayed blowback H&K P7 and Steyr GB, but that mechanism is (sadly) unpopular and those particular guns have been long out of production.
Fourth, let’s address the statement “if a round explodes in the chamber of any plastic gun, you probably don’t have the same kind of protection you’d get from a gun with metal frame and slide.” The slides of Glocks, and indeed, all other production centerfire handguns I can think of, are made of steel. The Glock, like the Sig-Sauer line of pistols, uses a modified Browning-type short-recoil with a reinforced locking block, which essentially comprises the reinforced chamber area of the barrel, and a cam-type action below that maintains the lockup integrity while the barrel is under recoil (i.e. while the bullet is travelling through the barrel). In fact, the entire operating mechanism of the gun is steel; the only stress the frame should see is in recoil (i.e. action of the slide once unlocked). There’s no reason a polymer-framed handgun would be more likely to “explode” than a steel frame pistol.
As for this specific model of handgun: after all that, I have to admit that I’m not a great fan of the Glock. I find its ergonomics–the frame angle, placement of levers, the funky trigger safety lever, grip texture, and so forth–to be wrong, at least for me. Its chunky shape isn’t partiularly easy to conceal, and the gun points all wrong for me–way too high. The trigger action is sort of crunchy, and the stock sights don’t acquire well. My preference for a stock pistol are the Sig P2XX series (aluminum framed) or the polymer frame H&K USP (I have yet to try out the P2000, but it looks interesting). Both are at the higher end of duty pistol prices, but not far out of reach. (I also like the ergonomics of both the Browning Hi-Power design and the CZ-75, but they’re single action and I’m not particularly fond of double action variants of either of these.)
DeadlyAccurate (heh), you don’t say what you want the gun for–self-defense, plinking, IPSC-type competition, what–but take that into consideration. The 9mmP is a fine round and inexpensive surplus ammo is widely available, but for a defensive gun I prefer the ‘major’ calibers like .40S&W and .45ACP, and these are almost a must for competition should you decide to go that way. Ultimately, though, you should select a pistol based not on what any ‘expert’ tells you is best, but on what feels and handles best for you and what is most reliable and appropriate for your intended purposes. If you like the Glock 17 and it shoots well for you, by all means buy it; it’s a quality firearm that isn’t going to ‘blow up in your face’ as long as you don’t fill the barrel with candle wax or fire a few hundred 9mm+P+++ rounds through it.
Good luck to you in whatever you choose.
Stranger