Clicker training is not right for every dog. Dogs which respond best to it are moderately intelligent dogs who have an eagerness to please. If the dog is very intelligent, the clicker method might not work as well for them.
My dog Polaris, ended up being one of those who was “too smart” for the clicker method. As an example, I was trying to teach her the command “off.” Whenever she would get up on the couch, I would tell her “off” and as soon as she jumped down, clicked and treated. She quickly figured out that the way to get a treat was to “disobey” so that I would give her the command and then a treat for obeying.
There could be a lot of reasons why he’s not responding to the clicker. Your dog may simply not like the sound of the clicker which he may associate with something unpleasant (you never know what’s going on in their two-watt brains.) A friend of mine had better results with shaking a bag of treats instead of clicking. The dog knew that sound meant food and was always delighted to hear it.
Your dog might respond better to the pop-and-praise method, especially if that was what was used during his earlier training. In the clicker method, you don’t say anything if the dog gets the command wrong-- you just wait until he gets it right and then praise. Dogs who are impatient or have a short attention span have trouble with this.
In the pop-and-praise method, you give mild correction when the dog gets the command wrong. (The word “pop” comes from giving a gentle tug on the dog’s choke collar during heel training.) My eldest dog, Bean, responded best to this method. I would give a command and she would try to obey, but if she got it wrong, I would say, “No*” and shake my head and repeat the command, guiding her if necessary, into the correct behavior.**
How does your dog respond to praise? Does he get really excited and happy when you tell him he’s a good boy? If he doesn’t, you may want to make his reward treats better. Give him pieces of hotdog instead of biscuits to give him an incentive to obey if your verbal praise isn’t enough to make him really happy.
Start and end each training session with an easy command that he knows well. Dogs, like children, can get frustrated towards learning if they’re not catching on quickly. You want to make training as fun as possible, and always end it on a positive note. Praise the beejezus out of him when he gets the command right and give him the rest of the hotdog.
- Say it in a “That’s not exactly right” tone rather than a sharp NO! of correction.
** Treat luring: use a treat to direct the dog into the position you want them to be in, like lowering it toward the floor when you want them to lie down.