All in all, looks relatively decent, but never thought this was a fight worth having anyway. I might be slightly more pleased with a winter solstice holiday rather than an Xmas holiday, but its not an issue I will consent to care about. Xmas displays at City Hall? Fine. Who cares? “Ceremonial deism” works ok too, especially if it gets the God Goons to shut up.
There should be a wall between church and state, but there never really has been, and I seriously doubt we have any reasonable chance of constructing one. Insisting on the equality of all doctrines, including atheism, Scientology, and Church of Subgenius (for I happen to believe that humor is one of the most important of the blessings of the Goddess) is a better strategy. Gets the ball out of our court, puts it squarely in theirs, so that the Pentecostals can duke it out with Opus Dei over Marianist doctrine, and the Wiccans can square off against the Amish.
Good clean fun if you haven’t a dog in the fight.