The preliminaries are done and here is the draw for the first round.
The rules are simple: There are 64 head-to-head matches and you vote for the winner of each match. You don’t have to vote for every match if you don’t want to. In the event of a tie I will make the call as to who wins. I’ll keep the voting open until 5:00 PM EST.
Here goes:
Ray Charles Vs Peter Gabriel
The Kinks Vs Melissa Etheridge
Yes Vs Bruce Springsteen
The Buffalo Springfield Vs The Byrds
Rush Vs Pearl Jam
Van Halen Vs The Supremes
Paul McCartney Vs Green Day
Fleetwood Mac Vs Simon & Garfunkel
Elvis Presley Vs The Beach Boys
Janet Jackson Vs The Eagles
The Velvet Underground Vs The Doors
The Sex Pistols Vs Alice In Chains
Johnny Cash Vs The Ramones
Frank Zappa Vs Bon Jovi
Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers Vs Foreigner
The Guess Who Vs Lynyrd Skynyrd
Charlie Parker Vs Blondie
Motley Crue Vs Rod Stewart
The Temptations Vs Led Zeppelin
Neil Young Vs Backstreet Boys
The Rolling Stones Vs Tony Bennett
Britney Spears Vs Miles Davis
The Carpenters Vs Madonna
Celine Dion Vs Willie Nelson
ABBA Vs Phil Collins
Genesis Vs George Harrison
Frank Sinatra Vs Dyran Duran
Pink Floyd Vs The Beatles
Paul Simon Vs Queen
The Steve Miller Band Vs Barbra Streisand
Aretha Franklin Vs Radiohead
Metallica Vs The Scorpions
Guns 'N Roses Vs Stone Temple Pilots
Sheryl Crow Vs Creedence Clearwater Revival
Chicago Vs Foo Fighters
Black Sabbath Vs KISS
Whitney Houston Vs James Taylor
Janis Joplin Vs The Commodores
The Who Vs The Human League
ZZ Top Vs The Four Tops
Thin Lizzy Vs R.E.M.
Smashing Pumpkins Vs Beastie Boys
Bad Company Vs Lou Reed
Joe Cocker Vs Billy Joel
Meatloaf Vs The Bee Gees
Ozzy Osborne Vs Styx
The Clash Vs Little Richard
U2 Vs Prince
Bush Vs Cher
Elton John Vs The Police
Alice Cooper Vs Soundgarden
Dire Straits Vs Aerosmith
Public Enemy Vs Creed
Garbage Vs John Lennon
Matchbox Twenty Vs AC/DC
Neil Diamond Vs Crosby, Stills & Nash
Donna Summer Vs Sade
The Grateful Dead Vs Marvin Gaye
Jimi Hendrix Vs Carole King
The Doobie Brothers Vs Rage Against The Machine
David Bowie Vs. Mariah Carey
Red Hot Chili Peppers Vs The Cars
Santana Vs Supertramp
Michael Jackson Vs Jerry Lee Lewis
And remember, this is just an exhibition so please, no wagering.
1.Charles
2.Kinks
4. Buffalo
5. Pearl Jam
7. Green Day
9.Elvis
11. Velvet
13. oooo…ouch…ummm Cash I guess
14. Zappa
15. Tom Petty
16. Skynyrd
19. LZ
20. o come on Neil Young
21. Stones
22. Davis
23. Carpenters
24. Nelson, Willie
28. odd first round paring(?) but Floyd by a nose
29. Queen
30. Miller
33. GnR
34. CCR
35. the Foo
36. Sabbath
39. Who
42. Pumpkins
45. Meat Loaf
49. Bush
51. Soundgarden
55. AC/DC
56. CSN(Y)
58. Dead
60. Doobie’s
62. RHCP
65. NIRVANA??? 66. NOFX 67. Yardbirds
dead0man
Red Hot Chili Peppers
dumb draw. talentless hacks get to the second round easily (eg either meatloaf or the bee gees don’t deserve to be there nor do bush when they inevitably defeat cher) while some respected bands will lose out in the first round because they were matched up with big name competition - pink floyd v beatles and aretha franklin v radiohead come to mind)
should have seeded them, like they do in the tennis.
besides, there’s some real losers in there. we’ve got to vote on donna summer and creed when groups such as blur, nirvana, the stone roses, joy division, new order, chemical bros, elvis costello, the cure, the smiths, pearl jam, bjork and weezer are not to be seen?
not enough spread over time periods + genres. bad 60’s + 70’s rock is way over-represented.
I agree that this format is flawed.
Perhaps if you list all 64 names and have us just pick 32.
Of course this still doesn’t address the obvious omissions.