I just wanted to share a few thoughts about my latest project…
I’m finally doing the recording that I’ve been talking about for the last few years. 4 composers, 16 songs will go on the album, plus I have another 9 pieces that I’m recording just to use as demos. It’s all voice and classical guitar, self-accompanied.
After much debate, I settled on performing everything ‘live’ to tape and editing the best performances together, as opposed to recording the guitar part and the voice part separately. Ultimately, I decided that what we’d lose in terms of separation and balance would be more than compensated by the ability for the guitar to accompany the voice, and for the voice to have its freedom of expression. None of these pieces were written to sound metronomic, after all.
The other big decision was to record the guitar naturally in a live acoustic rather than using the pick-up and adding reverb. This one wasn’t that hard, as I hate the sound of that piezo quack on any acoustic instrument.
So we’ve been recording in a church in downtown Toronto - the acoustic is gorgeous with a rich reverb. Outside noise is a bit of a challenge - we’re only a block or so north of Queen Street, which is quite busy. We’ve lost a bit of time to waiting for trucks to pass, distant sirens, etc., but it hasn’t been too bad.
We opted for 4 sessions of 3 hours each, and the sessions are spaced out by a week. I haven’t been spending any time listening back - the recordist has a very good ear for both music and sound issues, and my friend SC is following the score, and offering his advice. My biggest question is always ‘Did we get at least one good take of every bar, or should I do one more?’ Having someone else there to answer that question takes a ton of pressure off me. It’s also good to have someone listening for clams, clangs, buzzes and cushion farts. (The Dynarette cushion that I use to raise the instrument to the optimum angle is prone to squawk if the instrument moves against it - I now have a velvet cover for it so it won’t make as much noise…)
It’s a strange thing, this quest for an artificial perfection beyond what you would expect from a live performance. I’m trying to hold to the idea that the recording should reflect the very best of what you can do (because it doesn’t seem to be able to compensate for what you can’t do, at least not on my budget).
Having a week between pieces is one of the smartest moves I’ve ever made - it gives me just enough time to woodshed one set of pieces at a time without losing the overall groove of the project.
Speaking of which, I need to hit the woodshed again. I just wanted to take a few minutes to tell you what I’d been up to lately…