Right - I go away for two days, and now I’ve got all these different things to throw my two cents in over.
I have five guitars -
Big Bill is a Yamaha Classical from the early 1970s with a laminate top. Currently working as a baritone guitar.
L’il Ed is an Classical made for me in 2001 by Edward Klein.
La Mouette de neige is a Seagull steel-string acoustic made sometime in 1993.
Big Ed is a made in Mexico Power Telecaster - it has a stereo output with 3 single coil pickups and a Fishman piezoelectric pickup in the bridge. The signal can be split and eq’d separately and sent to two different amps. Very fun instrument.
Lorne is an 8-string custom made for Lorne Lofsky by David Wren of the 12th Fret sometime in 1983. Lorne is the one I use the least because it’s by far the most awkward of the lot - it’s essentially a Tele neck but with two extra strings, so there’s not a lot of room for your fingertips. On the other hand, it’s exquisitely simple to do Breau Barres…
And at this very moment, I have two other guitars on rent -
Ralph is an Art of Lutherie 12 string
Pierre is a La Patrie concert classical strung as a baritone instrument.
Speaking of baritone guitars, what I’ve been doing for the last couple of months is taking a regular classical and tuning it down a minor third. (1st - C#; 2nd - G#; 3rd - E; 4th - B; 5th - F#; 6th - C#) For a while, I tried using Extra Hard Tension strings, but the resulting tone quality was too flabby. What I now do is take a pack of Normal Tension strings, but put them on one string higher, so what would normally serve as a 2nd string B is now a 1st string C#. Then for the 6th string, I was using the E out of an Extra Hard Tension set, but it wasn’t cutting it, especially in a drop ‘D’ (well, okay, drop ‘B’, but this is confusing enough without bringing facts into it.) Now, I have a store of .052, .054 and .056 inch strings to use down there. I think when I get back home, I’m going to set Big Bill up with some .056, but for now, because Pierre the beater isn’t my guitar, I’m taking it easy on him with a .054.
So, repertoire - I have 3 songs by John Beckwith, 2 songs by William Beauvais, 2 Schubert arrangements, a Fauré arrangement and a Lenny Breau song all of which I’m polishing to record for a demo. In particular, the Schuberts and the Fauré are what require the Baritone guitar. The key I need for the Fauré is Db, and it’s just awkward on a standard tuning. On the Baritone, what looks like E major is Db. It’s the same with the Schubert one is in Gb, the other is in B, so on the Baritone that’s like playing in A and D, respectively.
The question had been asked about 7 string guitars - different guys come up with different tunings based on what they most want to do. My friend Paul tunes his seven in straight major thirds - C, G#, E, C, G#, E, C going from first to seventh. Other guys have tuned theirs in straight fourths. Bucky Pizzarelli, George Van Eps and Howard Alden all had/have a low A for the seventh string. Lenny Breau liked to have a high A for the first string. My 8 is usually kept in 1st - A, 2nd - E, 3rd - B, 4th - G, 5th - D, 6th - A, 7th - E, 8th - A, but I have been known to drop the 6th and 7th strings and play it as if it were a 3 string bass.
I don’t see why a Chapman isn’t a guitar - anytime you use a hammer on (ligado ascendente for us classical guys), you’re tapping rather than plucking the string. I remember the youngest member of Los Romeros played entire passages with left hand alone. Plus, you can pick/pluck/strum on a Chapman - you just don’t have any open string sounds…