I’ve always held a secret belief that Harry is descended from Godric Gryffindor. On my second reading of books 1-4, I caught the mention that Lily and James had lived in a place called Godric’s Hollow, and with the addition of Harry ending up with Gryffindor’s sword, the idea has pretty much been cemented in my head.
I know a lot of fans have jumped on the mention in OotP of Mark Evans, a Little Whinging kid that Dudley and his gang pounded on. I haven’t yet decided if I think the name’s just a coincidence. For all we know, Lily and Petunia had a brother that we don’t know about. Although, if the extended Evans family were in the area (and complete Muggles), there’s no reason I can think of that Petunia would be estranged. Of course, the Hypothetical Brother Evans could have married a witch or a squib, but then we’re forced to come to the conclusion that if there were another living Evans relative, especially one who was at least okay with the concept of magic, Harry wouldn’t have been left in Petunia and Vernon’s custody.
I think it’s most likely that the HBP will be a brandy-new character. A friend of mine suggested that possibly Krum is Bulgarian royalty, but I doubt Durmstrang is as halfblood-and-Muggle-friendly as Hogwarts.
If Aberforth is a prince, then logically so is Dumbledore. And I don’t think a halfblood would have been approved as Headmaster of Hogwarts.
(Just tossing out thoughts as they come to me now, please don’t look for anything coherent or cohesive from this point on.
)
I really dig Fretful Porpentine’s idea about McGonagall being a widow, and the possibility of her having lost a daughter to the Order. (And I also dig her name, but never mind that now.) It also ties in nicely with Rowling’s comments about how the marital stati (statuses? statia?) of the teachers at Hogwarts is something that will be covered in the future. (I don’t recall the cite at the moment, but another recent HP thread had all the new Book 6 stuff in it.)
Regarding Grimmauld Place, I had it in my head somewhere that Sirius had likely left all his possessions and property to Harry. If I’m wrong, then it will probably go to the Malfoys, or possibly Tonks. I had a momentary thought that she would be disinherited because she’d been blasted off the family tree, but then again, so had Sirius.
And I agree that Dumbledore will likely go to the Great Quidditch Pitch in the Sky before the end of the series, quite possibly in a “straw that broke the Chosen One’s back” manner, giving Harry just the incentive needed to kill Voldemort or do something else daunting and dangerous.
I think I should stop now and do some work. :o