Did you guys coordinate your tag-teaming on me?
I searched on the J-Archive for “astrology,” astrological," “horoscope,” and “zodiac,” and found a total of 510 clues that used those terms. Since there have been nearly 423,000 clues in the modern version of the show (since 1984), that’s slightly more than one tenth of one percent of all clues.
Some of those were one-offs in categories that otherwise had nothing to do with astrology; but on at least 67 shows (out of a total to date of 8,465), there were whole categories devoted to astrology. So about 0.8% of all shows had a category on astrology, and a larger percentage had at least a passing reference to it.
Obviously, these are not particularly large numbers, and in fact smaller than I might have guessed. Mythology figures in more than twice as many clues. But I still think there is an important principle at stake.
Some of these clues are pretty innocuous by any standard: “Sissy Spacek was born on Christmas Day, so this is her sign.” It does not make any truth claim about the tenets of astrology, merely acknowledges its existence. If that’s all Jeopardy did, I wouldn’t object strongly.
But this one from the same show, “People born under this fishy sign, like Tommy Tune, are often slim & make excellent dancers,” strongly implies that astrology has a factual basis. I estimate that well over half of the 510 are in this mold. I think this is insidious and should have no place on Jeopardy.
Let’s consider your claimed equivalence between mythology and astrology as presented on Jeopardy (and other popular media). I hope we all agree that neither accurately describes reality as we know it.
However, AFAIK (and I know I can count on Dopers to correct me if I’m wrong) there is virtually no one alive today who sincerely believes that any of the gods of ancient mythology (e.g., Zeus, Jupiter, Thor, etc.) literally exist as deities with the powers and personalities ascribed to them by the legends.
The same cannot be said of astrology. According to Gallup in 2005, and Harris (PDF) in 2009, about a quarter of Americans believe in astrology. That’s more than 80 million people in the U. S. alone who accept as true a pseudoscience that has repeatedly been definitively disproven.
Does the show treat any any other pseudoscience – homeopathy, flat earth theory, moon landing hoax – this way? No, I don’t think it does, or should. And it shouldn’t treat astrology that way either, IMHO.
Really? I didn’t realize that!
As @BigT says, astrology is (mostly) harmless, especially compared to the morass of pernicious lies and conspiracies that abound in our country today. If I could magically wave a wand and convert every anti-vaxxer and Big Lie believer into (only) an astrology believer, I certainly would. But that doesn’t mean that any pseudoscience should get a free pass on one of the few popular media outlets that promotes facts, science, and critical thinking.