Kimstu
October 24, 2025, 7:16pm
441
No, I think you’re still kind of missing the point here. The central idea is that in the bear’s natural environment out in the woods, like most other wild animals, it is far more likely to leave you alone if you leave it alone than to try to harm you.
As I’ve pointed out before , in a different environment such as an office building elevator, most woman would (rightly) be far more afraid of the presence of a random bear than of a random man.
Kimstu:
ISTM that a lot of the subtext in this discussion involves respondents’ making unspoken assumptions about why the man is out there in the woods.
Everybody knows that the bear is wandering around in the woods because that’s just where bears live. (And shit, natch, and do all the rest of their bear business.)
But there is a popular perception, stoked (and not just among women) by centuries of sensationalist crime reporting and fiction, that if a lone man is out in the woods then there’s a significantly heightened probability that he’s some kind of crazy predator. Of course you’d rather encounter a bear just going about his/her bear business than run that kind of risk.
I’m willing to bet that almost all of the women who responded that they’d rather encounter a bear than a man when alone in the woods would switch their answer if instead the context was, say, alone in an elevator in a busy office building during the workday.
That’s a situation in which a man is presumed by default to be going about normal man business rather than acts of crazy predation. A bear in an elevator, in the other hand, is far more likely to be distressed and aggressive rather than just doing normal bear business. (Although maybe the bear came into town to see her lawyer or something, I don’t know her bear life.)