The one that got away

So last night I couldn’t sleep. I had memories of a girl who I liked very much running through my head and I couldn’t stop thinking about what couldve been. I liked her a lot if you can’t tell and she felt much the same way I believe. But nothing ever happened because I didn’t try. So now I just lie in bed and think “where were you?”.

I don’t know I feel bad about it but know I just have to move on. It’s like a part of my life is incomplete and can never be filled again. And don’t even consider trying for her again, not gonna happen.

Anyways, anybody have similar stories? Somebody let me know I’m not alone here. :slight_smile:

Three little words that every woman longs to hear: “May I sit?”

I was in a restaurant in a little resort town the other night. Because I had social commitments later, I grabbed dinner a little early. The dining room was practically empty. I chatted a bit with some wmen seated next to me, then they left . A couple more women walked in.

Then SHE walked in. Cute Blonde Pigtails Fresh Off the Beach Yummy Girliness. (Or Girly Yumminess.)

When I finished paying my check, I walked over and said hi. We had a nice little conversation. I didn’t find out much about her except for some basic demographic information. For all I know, she’s a puppy-kicking psycho bitch. But my gut told me that she’s a really awesome person. And my gut’s usually right about that.

I felt a little awkward just sitting down with her, what with the other diners and the waitresses right there. And her name is Diana, which immediately made me wonder if it was DianaG, which, for some reason, kind of freaked me out. (I don’t know why. That would have been pretty cool, actually.) I could tell from the expression on her face that she wanted me to sit down. So I said “It was nice meeting you, goodbye.”

So, fellow Dopers, I present to you my ass. It desperately needs a few swift kicks.

Anyway, I haven’t stopped thinking about her.

Welcome to my life.

I posted this in another thread:

Most women are not attracted to men who are not confident. It’s that lack of confidence that will kill your chances EVERYTIME!

Well, this was 1984…

Oh, well, I had a 30-minute layover in the Charlotte airport last week. I went out thru security to smoke. Spotted this really hot guy smoking. Finished my cig and who did I bump into in the “going back in” security line? Smoking hot guy. I start chatting him up and we get through security and part ways. Both start racing through the airport to get to Concourse E, so we ended up tag teaming, helping each other blow past the slower travelers (I should say “less rushed and nicotine-filled travelers.”)

We had only enough time to exchange names and a handshake before he went off to Cleveland and I went off to Tallahassee.

So sad. I refer to him as my single-serving husband. He was perfect for me… for those blissful 20 minutes of our relationship. And now I have no way to track him down. :: sigh ::

Interesting. I always thought of “The one that got away” as someone you had in the first place, not someone you gazed at longingly from a subway window. With regard to the OP, I suppose I don’t have anyone that got away. I have asked myself, of people who I was in long relationships with, and I truly cared about, “What if one of us tried just a little bit harder?”

When I first moved here 14 years ago, I started dating a guy- I’ll call him Travis, because that’s his name. Travis was outgoing, funny, charming, sexy, good-looking, and seemed to know everyone everywhere we went. I looooved Travis, and I just knew he was the one for me and we would be together forever and happy always. But then it turned out that Travis was physically abusive. After three months of trying to change him, I gave up. Now he’s been married for ten years, and I’m still single. I often wonder if he treats his wife like he did me.

See, should have used #9 Dorrance hooks.

I agree, she didn’t “get away”, she was a “never took a chance”.

Tomato-tomato

I missed my big chance yesterday.

A guy started a conversation with me on the subway about the book I was reading. He was really really attractive AND he managed to work the fact that he was recently divorced into a 45 second conversation.

Then the train hit my stop and I couldn’t think of anything else to do but say good-bye and get off at my stop…I was tempted to stay on the train but I didn’t, oh well.

Scotty, you are not alone.

Almost 19 years ago, I was at a Dead show several hundred miles from home. At the end of the show, the most beautiful hippie chick imaginable came up to me and said, “Don’t I know you from somewhere?” Turned out we lived a couple of blocks from each other. She was just camping wherever, and I had a motel room, so I invited her over. She said maybe. Later she showed up. We ended up driving home together.

We spent the next couple of years almost hooking up. Shared a lot of laughs and a few almost intimate moments, but, like you, I never really tried to close the deal. Chickenshit, mostly. Eventually, I just married someone else (another tale of woe for another day).

Last time I saw her was 1995 at another Dead show, one of the last before Jerry’s death. I had a wife and an 8 month old baby. She was married and pregnant. We chatted a bit, shared a last lingering gaze, and then that was that.

In the almost 15 years since then, I have to admit that not a month has gone by that I haven’t thought of her. Sometimes I would dream about her, and then weeks would go by where I would think about her almost constantly.

I’d been contemplating divorce for quite a while, and last February decided I just couldn’t take it any more and started making plans to move out (which I did last month). Also at that time, I decided to try one more time to find her (had been checking occasionally for a while), and magically, she now had a website for her business. I gathered all the courage I could muster and sent a “hey, remember me?” email.

She did.

We’ve been emailing regularly since then, sometimes 20 times a day. She’s offered me a lot of support in moving out, and at the very least we are very close friends again.

I don’t know if anything more will come of this - taking it really slowly as I’m in the process of adjusting myself and my kids to the new reality - but just being in contact is an absolute rush.

The best relationships are truly the ones you never got to have. No fighting and the imaginary sex is amazing!

Yeah, seriously. I mean while people are wishing for shit, you might as well pine over that time Kate Beckinsale got away.:dubious:

I had a boyfriend back in junior high, a new student that year. The way he asked me was by tucking a heart-shaped box of chocolates in my locker near Valentine’s Day. Super sweet kid, very funny, nice guy and managed to be creative and bold without being corny and overwhelming. I wasn’t going to say NO.

He moved away at some point. It was quite a while ago (like 15 years or something) so the details are fuzzy, but I missed him for quite some time and I’ve thought of him fondly occasionally since then, but I never thought much of it until a year ago when I caught up with him on Facebook.

Last Valentine’s Day I opened my book bag and was only a little surprised to find a heart-shaped box of chocolates in there.

He’s sitting on the other end of the couch watching Die Hard, probably getting at least a little annoyed that I’m still online even though it was my idea to watch a movie. I still look at him sometimes and think “Hey, you’re Ben!” and wonder how we got here, where we’re spending our lives together and having a baby and house shopping and blahblah. It’s crazy. I never would have thought.

Anyway, sometimes you do get them back. But I agree with MeanOldLady, they can’t have “got away” and you can’t “get them back” if you never had them in the first place.

If I’m a cop chasing a burglar and he escapes and I exclaim “he got away!” nobody is going to say “he can’t get away if you didn’t have him to begin with.” I don’t have a problem with the OP’s usage.

Holy shit… me too!

Last night I dreamt of the pretty, young Dutchwoman who did everything she could to get my attention whenever I was in the grocery store where she worked in Rotterdam.

This was about thirteen years ago but I still think about her more often than I should. I remember her doing things like: upon noticing me in the checkout line across the store, suddenly leaving her post (often the cheese-counter) to grab some small item like a candy bar in order to purchase it–just to get near me in the line so she could smile at me and say “hi”.

I was in such a deep depression when I lived in the Netherlands that often I wouldn’t notice things like this. Or even when I did, I felt so down that I didn’t have the strength to pursue her (even though it would have taken less than zero pursuit effort on my part because, for some reason, she REALLY wanted to date me).

Finally one day, I decided that the next time I saw her at the store, I would ask her out–no hemming, no hawing, no beating around the bush or meekly asking for her number–I was just going to tell her straight out, “Hey. I’m going to the Blauwe Vis (or Bambu, or someplace) on Friday night. I think it’d be great if you came with me.”

I knew she would drop any plans she might have and accompany me in a heartbeat. I knew there was virtually no chance in hell that she would say no.

As I was going through the aisles, picking up my usual *Goudse kaas, Chocomel, komkommer, boerenbrood and Spa (met gas)**, I spotted Annemiek (the lass in question) kneeling down stocking some produce. A customer–a decent-looking young man about her age–was chatting with her.

“Hmm…”, my overly-analytical and rather depressed brain said, “I suppose that must be her boyfriend or some other suitor then. Funny, I never got any impression that she was ‘spoken for’… Well shit! I’ve walked all the way over here and now I’m next to her and the guy, they’ve both looked up and noticed me, and she is suddenly smiling as if she won the lottery, and he suddenly appears rather glum… what the fuck do I say now?”

I stumbled and stuttered just a bit then finally said something like: “Hi Annemiek! Hey I wanted to ask you something, actually…”

“What!!! What is it!!! What would you like to know???” She eagerly replied. In retrospect I realize she had been waiting a long time for me to ask her out–wondering what in the hell was taking me so long–and she thought I was finally about to, which indeed I had been planning to, so I said…

“Ummm… I didn’t see any of the 6-month old Gouda in the cheese case, do you know if I could maybe get some cut?” She looked at me a little disappointed, but also realized I was possibly just trying to get her away from the young man so I could speak to her in private. So she walked with me over to the cheese-counter while the Dutch youngster somewhat abjectly stayed behind.

We reached the counter, she picked up a block of the cheese I had requested. It was laying out in plain sight along with 10 other chunks just like it. She knew I didn’t care about the cheese. She smiled even more brightly, looked into my eyes playfully and knowingly and said, "So is this all you wanted to ask me about?

It’s amazing to me now. That my balls had instantly shrunk to the size of poppy seeds just because some guy was chatting up the woman who was obviously head-over-heals crazy for me. I knew it, and she knew I knew it. And suddenly I was at one of those Forks in the Road…

“Yeah. You know I always come to you with any questions about cheese. You’re the cheese expert, Annemiek!” I managed a weak smile, took the cheese from her, and quickly turned on my cowardly heel before I could absorb the shock, disappointment, and–most likely–disdain, broadcast from that wonderful face.

I suppose I saw her around again a few times–here and there, at the store or in the neighborhood. I’m sure we probably nodded or waved to each other, but nothing more.

I felt only shame at those times. As for her–what does a girl say to the man who, not long ago, she would have done anything and everything for… but who had inexplicably rejected her desire; painting every square inch of his body with the label “LOSER!!!” in bright, red paint?

*Gouda cheese; Chocomel brand chocolate milk; English cucumber; farmer’s bread; Spa brand sparkling bottled water.

Wow… I hadn’t read Sunspace’s story about Anna-Marie before I wrote mine. That name is rather similar to Annemiek (pronounced: Ahn-na-MEEK).

“Thoughtcrime does not entail death: thoughtcrime is death.”