Just saw this today.
Saw it in 2D, and that was fine with me. I wish I could have seen it in 3D, but it wasn’t an option. And I really doubt I’d pay to see it again in a theater just for that.
As others have mentioned, I thought they did a pretty good job with character continuity. If you remember a character from the past, they are pretty consistent and did a nice job updating it for today’s audience.
The other thing I thought they did great was the voices. To me, there was very little difference in what memories I had of the characters and how they sounded today. Kids wouldn’t care as much, obviously, but for an adult with better memories of the voices from those animated specials, I was surprised at how close they were.
One strong memory of the “Peanuts” strip that I never enjoyed as a kid was the Snoopy as the WWI flying ace, fighting the Red Baron, and all that nonsense. I never got that as a kid, and as an adult, it was still painfully unfunny. Charles Schulz had some sort of a weird connection with the “Sopwith Camel”, and I always wondered if he got one as a toy when he was a kid or something. But that “theme” always fell flat for me, and IMO they used that a bit too much in the movie.
I also enjoyed the dancing that copied the old Christmas special exactly. There were a couple of new characters they added and their dances were equally unique and funny. Kids and adults both laughed during the dance scenes.
I don’t remember any of the little girls having a crush on Pig Pen, but that was an ok addition. And they gave Good Ol’ Charlie Brown a nicer finish than he’s ever had. He wasn’t the perma-failure that he was from the old strips, but I think that was to be expected in today’s PC environment. It was even better than the “Merry Christmas Charlie Brown!” finish from the original Christmas special in that he was seen as a good guy by everyone (including Lucy!) for much of the movie.
One thing I am curious about… I haven’t followed Peanuts for a long time, but I don’t recall the “little red-haired girl” ever being seen. She was always out of the picture, someone Charlie Brown always admired from afar. She is “unmasked” so to speak in this movie, and I was curious if this is the first time she has ever been animated… Anyone know?
I understand why they decided to show her in the movie, but if this was the first time she has ever been seen, I would have preferred if they kept her face hidden from view. I always liked the mystery of “the little red-haired girl”.
Nothing special here, but a very good “G” rated movie for kids. Very tame by today’s standards, and I think that was a good thing. No need to go crazy with this brand. I don’t think Schulz would have objected to this movie at all.