The Republican Party needs to Pay Attention

One question for the Republican party is where to go after Tax Reform and, unfortunately, I feel like they might go back to working on killing ObamaCare.

The thing is, though, if they do that, then it means that the leadership is going to continue to be locked in internal politics for much or most of 2018, trying to find a solution to the health care problem, as well as trying to run mid-term elections. That’s going to continue to swamp out their general oversight of what all is going on in the world.

And the thing is, while the Right has been focused on taxes and health care, the Left hasn’t been doing any better at watching what the Executive branch is doing. They’ve been more wrapped up in Trump calling Elizabeth Warren “Pocahontas” and Russian Collusion, than they have been on the state of the Union.

The only real world thing that has bumped its way to the headlines every once in a while is North Korea, but all of the other realpolitik stuff is also pretty gloomy, and Trump is not up to the occasion to manage it.

Trump probably wants to can NAFTA. He’s going to cut H-1B visas, which could cause some major issues for most of the high-tech world (which is currently, predominantly located in the US) and cause much of it (and its money) to move abroad. He’s building up to a trade war with China. He’s handing Syria to Russia and spurring on the rest of the Middle East to have a good ol’ fashioned religious war. We need better cybersecurity or cyber-response methods, and we really need a national CTO with the power and insight to lead the way on that, not Jared Kushner and whoever this lady is. And, of course, there’s North Korea and the Department of State.

Overall, I regret to say that the only positive thing that I can think of that the President has done, as Executive, is to decide to start burning poppy fields in Afghanistan. Beyond that, the planet is basically being allowed to drift into a general state of lawlessness and disorder. And even if you might not care too much about that from a humanitarian standpoint, that’s still a big problem on the front of general commerce and national safety. And most people do care about the humanitarian side of things.

I, also, personally think that the nation has a domestic issue with a lack of cross-pollination of ideas, because of social media, and increased brain drain from South to North as people become more accustomed to moving away from where they grew up. The end result is going to be increased partisanship and, more worryingly, a continued decrease in the reasonableness and education of voters on the Republican side, leading to a decline in policy and a reduced ability to find compromise and shared values with the other side. There was already more serious talk of Californian secession than I’d ever really have expected in my lifetime, and I fear that that’s only going to become ever more likely, even if we get better leaders as an option in 2020. That’s going to be a slow boat to turn, and so it is important to get it started changing direction if there is any policy whatsoever that can do it.

I think it’s reasonably certain that the Republican party will lose the House in 2019, and suddenly that will become a major issue for the general functioning of the government. The Intelligence and Ethics committees of the House will be run by Democrats and they’ll start putting the gas pedal down on investigations into the President, and exposing all of it to the press as loudly as they can. Unless the President is actually clean, that’s going to be all everyone’s thinking about for at least most of 2019, if not all of the way through 2020 and the next election.

Basically, 2018 is the only year available to try and make sure that the world doesn’t go to hell while we’re waiting for a new President.

If you, the Republican party, choose instead to focus on health care reform, then you’re going to discover that there is a worse thing in life than buying cancer kids chemotherapy.

Please put partisan politics to the side for the next few months and pass some policy that makes sure that the ship is at least on a safe heading before you get pulled back into insanity, the election, and 2019.

Obamacare is dead. The taxpayer-funded subsidies were an integral part of Obamacare, but we can no longer afford them. Tax revenue is dramatically reduced, so we’ll need to squeeze every penny.

I’m curious what opportunities you think “the Left” has passed up. One specific suggestion seen at SDMB is that Democratic Senators should filibuster spending resolutions — what do you think of that?

Not to mention they just repealed the mandate, and i doubt the House is going to fight them on that.

I’m not exactly sure what you are saying the GOP needs to pay attention to but:

Those things lead to more “cross-pollination”, not less.

There is no “serious talk of California secession”. There was this sone nutty guy, but he moved to Russia.

Been there, done that any number of times already. This is nothing new.

You over-estimate the role the US plays in whether the world “goes to hell” or not.

Obamacare should have been repealed in its entirety already. We need to stop pussyfooting around it and just do it.

Then elect people with a backbone.

Do more important things first.

Also: And come up with an answer that actually deals with the doubled health care spending of the US, compared to other nations, not just trying to reduce Medicare/Medicaid spending by 5% or whatever.

If you don’t have an actual idea to work on then shut up and do things that you do have ideas on.

If you replace it with something like Medicare for all, you’d probably have 95% of the public supporting you.

Do you also oppose the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act? If so, Why?

Because he can google it, you trickster you.

OP, I have no idea why you think Republicans would be interested in any of that stuff, though I was amused by the idea of Democrats doing anything but falling down an open elevator shaft.

Cross-pollination of ideas? We have anime Nazis now, baby.

I’ve been asked some dumbass questions on this board. That’s right up there with the worst of them.

Getting out there and pitching good policy on a wide array of topics, and calling out poor policy for what it is, and not just in a “the sky is falling” sort of way, like with tax reform.

Basically, trying to get things like this further out into the general public:

https://lawfareblog.com/america-bad-wingman-middle-east

I’m reasonably certain that spending is dictated by Congress. While one might disagree with Republican budgets, they’re still within some range of reason (despite “the sky is falling” rhetoric around them - just the same as the Republicans do with a Democratic budget).

Between stopping your opponent from doing something that is reasonable, but you disagree with, and stopping a petulant baby from destroying things out of stupidity, boredom, and maliciousness - I think it’s reasonable to say that the Democrats also have a similar job as the Republicans, to focus on reality for a year. It’s just less important that they do so, since they’re not in charge.

While it may be that the Republican party is the party of the religious, it’s also the party of business and the wealthy. The former might not give a damn. The latter do. Global security and national stability are good for business.

While it may well be that Republicans in Congress are mostly religious, I’d venture to guess that nearly all of them are only interested in writing Christian legislation to the extent that it is necessary for them to placate their base. But they’re all genuinely interested in making American businesses able to maintain global dominance. It’s no act.

I agree with everything in this post (sorry John, in case that gets you a ribbing from your friends). The OP also said:

What are you talking about?

  1. Syria was a Russian client way before Trump had anything to do with it.

  2. What would you have us do to put a stop this? Wag our finger at Putin? Put a strongly-worded letter in their file at the UN? Impose a no-fly-zone? Kill some Russians?

Got it.

There’s a very simple and straightforward way to do this. It’s the way just about every other country does it, but it’s anathema to Republican dogma (and also to some Democrats), so it’s not going to even get on the public radar screen, much less be adopted. It’s price controls on pharmaceuticals and possibly medical procedures. It usually goes hand-in-hand with universal health care, but it could be implemented without that.

I have also proposed solutions in previous threads that would be Republican-friendly, but I’d rather this thread not get lost on that discussion.

I’m convinced the Democrats are trying to play some sort of long game here and hope that the Republicans will eventually have to start impeachment proceedings on their own. It’s quite amazing to me that they are not pushing harder unless it’s deliberate.