"The same people that ____ are the ones that also _____"

Argh…recently I’ve encountered more than a few people who, in the midst of an argument concerning ethics or morality or religion or law, will attempt to portray their opponents as hypocrites by saying something like this:

“The same people who are fighting for the rights of unborn children are the ones that also endorse the death penalty.”

or

“The same people who close their minds to the possibility of paranormal phenomenae are the ones that also go to church and pray to God.”

And so forth.

Really? How the fuck do you know that I fall neatly into your narrowly-defined stereotype?

I think that the same people who make these kinds of statements are also the ones that will say, “well, you can’t prove that God doesn’t exist, therefore my belief in Him is justified.”

People who complain that they are the victims of overbroad generalization are the same sort of people who make sweeping generalizations.

?

You’re kidding, right?

He’s not kidding, but God is.

I have to agree with the original rant, and expand on it… nothing kills a political debate faster than “… and the democrats always say X” or “…and these are the same guys who always say Y”.
But what’s even worse, imho, is the “and we all know that if a democrat did X, we’d never hear the end of it” or “if a republican did Y, the press would hound them into oblivion”.
I mean, how do you possibly respond to such a statement? It just kills the discussion dead.

I knew you’d say that. You always say things like that.

Hitler said things like that, too.

You and me guy, we are the only one’s with a grip on rational argument. The rest are fucking assholes.

Why do you love Hitler so much?

"The same people who steal 2-liter bottle flats from behind the Smith’s grocery store in thier BMWs at 2 AM are the same people who do homebrew beer and are usually drunk most of the time on weekends but still manage to provide for thier wives (hum, I actually only have one “wife”, but pay to sustain 3 “concubines” in various apartments around town- how do I sufficiently account for them?) and children (don’t even get me started on them) with out ever thinking of the REAL VICTIMS of thier crimes!

:eek: Ohh, what was this thread about?

Of course. I was hoping I wouldn’t have to use the winking smiley.