National broadcasters like John Madden are so much better that local broadcasters it’s not even funny. I’m sorry, but Madden is literally not one of the 1,000 worst color men in sports.
Joe Carter has done both Blue Jays and Cubs broadcasts now and he’s amazing. Pitches are “down and low,” as opposed, I guess, to down and high. He says things like “Once you start thinking about it, it’s mental.” I’ve never heard him offer ANY insight, which mirrors how he used to play.
Then we had Brian Williams doing Blue Jays games. Williams is a bigwig at CBC who does Olympics broadcasts, which he’s pretty good at, but he doesn’t know baseball. Every ball is “WELL HIT!” A player will pop a ball up and Williams will scream “WELL HIT!!” and it’ll be caught by the second baseman thirty feet behind the base. A guy will ground out, cleanly thrown out at first, and Williams will shriek he’s safe. Anytime it’s 3-1 he’d ask his partner “Will he be swinging here, John Cerutti?” (always with the full name)
He can’t remember names. I don’t mean Harry Caray screwing up names; I mean calling guys by the names of other guys who haven’t played here in years. If he attempts to refer to Kelvim Escobar by name I guarantee he’ll call him “Juan Guzman” two thirds of the time. He’s prone to involing the most absurdly cliches stereotypes. He freely insults players who don’t give nice interviews. His color man, John Cerutti, eventually got tired of him and just started contradicting him:
WILLIAMS: Juan Guzman is warming up in the pen…
CERUTTI: No, he’s not. That’s Kelvim Escobar.
WILLIAMS: Here’s Cal Ripken. Ripken holds the record for the most consecutive games played, John.
CERUTTI: Yes, I know that.
WILLIAMS: That’s WELL HIT to left! And it drops foul just behind the dugout. The next batter is Dave Martinez.
CERUTTI: Segui.
WILLIAMS: Remember, fans, tomorrow we’ll have live Blue Jays baseball for you at 7 Eastern, that’s 6 Central, 5 Mountain, 4 Pacific, 8 Atlantic and 8:30 in Pogey Lineup, Newfoundland.
CERUTTI: Thrilling.
WILLIAMS: I was chatting with Dave Martinez just before the game…
(Albert Belle hits a home run)
WILLIAMS …and he was telling me he always enjoyed playing in Montreal, where I once knew a girl, who could stick a whole…
CERUTTI: Home run for Belle, Brian.
WILLIAMS: Oh, Mr. Personality. Anyway, this game just seems to be dragging on. They should do something about the length of games.
CERUTTI: It’s only the first inning. We’ve been here less than fifteen minutes.
WILLIAMS: Now batting is Glenn Davis.
CERUTTI: Eric Davis.
WILLIAMS: He grounds out to the second baseman.
CERUTTI: It was a foul ball, strike one.
WILLIAMS: (Giggles)