They have 4 albums you should know about. They start off very garage rock-y and get more polished as Jack becomes a better musician. Meg never really improves (some say this is a feature not a bug, I am on the fence).
The first album you should know is their second album **De Stijl **which got them the attention of the indie kids back in 2000. It’s a solidly fun, dirty blues rock album.
Notable tracks (I’ll only list a couple, as the whole album is really good)
You’re Pretty Good Lookin’ (For a girl)
Hello Operator
Their next album White Blood Cells contained their first mega hit “Fell in love with a girl.” which doesn’t sound much like their other music, but was probably still their biggest hit to date and has been covereda 1001 timesby now.
It also had a ton of other great songs that largely got overshadowed by the mega sucess of Fell in Love. These include
Dead Leave on the Dirty Ground
the previously linkedHotel Yorba
and the underrated (yet still popular) We’re Going to be Friends
So, that was their “unknown indie rock period” in the sense that those songs were all written before they made the cover of Rolling Stone, so to speak.
After the success of White Blood Cells they released the album that was so popular I got sick of them Elephant.
This is the album that had the songs that were played on popular radio every 5 minutes from 2003-2005 including
The Hardest Button to Button
Seven Nation Army
their really fantastic version ofI Just Don’t Know What to Do With Myself
Like White Blood Cells Elephant has lots of other great tracks that didn’t get airplay like Girl, You Have No Faith In Medicine.
So then some time passed, Jack got together with Brendan Benson and formed The Racontoures who have a few hits of their own. You might know Steady as She Goes. They are worth checking out on their own, and are more traditionally rock. He also produced a really excelent album by Loretta Lynn and worked on the Cold Mountain soundtrack.
Then the band comes back with Get Behind me Satan, which is very very different from Elephant or anything else they have done. You may know their songMy Doorbell from this album best. Also worth a mention
I’m Lonely But I Ain’t That Lonely Yet
Forever For Her is Over for Me
Take Take Take
Then came Icky Thump in 2007 (which, holy crap their last real album was that long ago?)
which didn’t do a ton for me so I will let someone else suggest listening tracks, but it was pretty well liked as well. And then that’s where it sort of stopped.