The worst intersection in Ann Arbor just got worse.

Looky here at this map, and you will see a nexus where Nixon Road runs north/south, and Green Road and Dhu Varren Road run into Nixon with a slight offset. Believe it or not, this is NOT two separate tee intersections: it is a single four-way-stop intersection (switch to satellite view, and you can see more clearly how close/far the roads are). As you might expect from this bizarre geometry, traffic through-put is miserable, and there is much confusion about right of way, owing in large part to the fact that it takes so long for any single car to clear the intersection.

This week a major construction project kicked off on Pontiac Trail, a major north-south thoroughfare about a mile west of this. With the closure of that road, all of its traffic is being detoured onto Nixon, through the miserable intersection I just described. To help improve traffic flow, the city has temporarily ripped out the stop signs on Nixon Road, which effectively does turn this into two independent tee intersections. Want to get from Green to Dhu Varren? Here’s what you’re supposed to do now:

  1. pull up to the stop sign, signal for a right turn.
  2. when northbound traffic on Nixon has cleared, turn right onto Nixon.
  3. travel 15 feet north on Nixon, signal for a left turn.
  4. When southbound traffic on Nixon has cleared, turn left onto Dhu Varren.

Same thing in reverse for getting from Dhu Varren to Green.

That’s how it’s supposed to work for the next five months or so. There are flashing signs and flags on Green and Dhu Varren warning people of the new traffic pattern: “NIXON ROAD DOES NOT STOP”. There are also signs on Nixon telling those drivers that they no longer have to stop (but should be careful nonetheless).

So what’s the problem?

People who have driven through this intersection for years continue to treat it as a four way stop. There are no stop signs on Nixon anymore - they’ve been physically removed and placed into storage - but drivers are continuing to stop there. I came through yesterday afternoon and this morning, making the exact crossings I described above, and in my efforts to be a good citizen, I tried to yield right of way to oncoming traffic from Nixon, but it was impossible: every single car on Nixon stopped, and when they thought it was my “turn”, they waited until I had to go.

As annoying as this is, it’s actually an interesting instance of social proof. With the stop signs gone and all sorts of unusual warning signs in place, there’s a ton of uncertainty as drivers approach the intersection. Not sure what to do? Well, the guy in front of you has stopped, so I guess it must be that you’re supposed to stop too, even though there’s no goddam stop sign.

Possibly making matters worse was the cop in his squad car parked on the grass at the southest corner. Rather than being out there ushering Nixon traffic through, I think he was just there to quickly pick up the pieces from the inevitable crash, or stop the fistfight that was sure to come up when someone violated someone else’s right-of-way after waiting 15 minutes to get to the intersection (remember, traffic through there is now pretty much doubled). But his visible presence probably led a lot of people to believe that they were sure to get a ticket if they blew through the phantom stop sign without stopping.

Yep…gonna be a fun five months. Hopefully people driving on Nixon will get the idea soon, and throughput will go up. Until then, passing through that intersection will be a painful experience for everyone.

Lucky it’s only a temporary situation, but from the map it looks like a great place to put a roundabout.

They should just take a corner out of the plot on the southwest side of the intersection and punch a straight road through the from east to west

+1

Though, from my experience of living in AA for 25 years, it might take them a decade or so to learn how to navigate it. Fortunately that spot is less U traffic and more towny traffic, IIRC. It might make more sense (and impinge on private property less) to move Dhu Varren so that it intersects opposite Green.

There’s a famous intersection just south of there, Nixon and Bluett. The street sign kept getting stolen, until they figured out why and started putting Bluett on top. I suppose that was funnier 30 years ago.

I don’t have anything to contribute to the OP but I used to live in A[sup]2[/sup] and my dad lived on Haverhill Ct., so I remember that intersection well. But that was in 1979. We also used to laugh at Nixon/Bluett every time we drove by.

“Dhu Varren”? A Vietnamese name?

Irish.

Don’t forget the intersection of Gott/Hiscock, right near Felch Street.

I had friends that lived between Felch and Hiscock. They had a notion to paint their house in “period” Victorian colors which sounds fine on paper but they ended up with royal purple with electric yellow trim. The hideousness was awe-inspiring. They moved away a few years ago – they claim for work, but I think the neighbors drove them off with torches and pitchforks due to the paint job.

I only know tangentially of that intersection as I was almost never up that side of town when I lived in Ann Arbor. I worked at Borders Group HQ which was far to the south, and lived south of the river in the Old First Ward. Funny but I think of Northside as VERY university dominated and feeding North Campus, as almost no large employers are up thataway now the pharmaceutical research facility closed and UM took over the space. But I imagine there’s a lot of residential development up around Nixon, it was already gathering steam when I left in 2004.

I’m not surprised at the problem described in the OP – of all the places I’ve lived, Michigan is the one where four-way stop etiquette is almost a religion. Telling people NOT to stop where they’ve always stopped, is kinda like telling them to stab their grandmother. j/k, but only a little.

I live in Michigan now, and I agree with this. Drivers here are in general no worse nor better than those living in other states, but over-courteousness at 4-way stop signs can get almost annoying at times here.

“Go ahead.”
“No, you!”
“No I insist, go for it.”
“Go, I’m sure you were first to stop and you’re on my right…”
“Well I’m not sure and there are now four of us sitting here at an impasse and I do not wish to appear rude…”

Etc and all done with hand gestures.

I’m not familiar with the OP’s intersection but I can envision it. And for more Michigan driving weirdness, there’s the Michigan left. Which makes a weird sort of sense for very high-traffic intersections, but also makes it a royal pain in the ass to get from A to B in some areas (Hall Road in Macomb county, I am looking at YOU.)

I lived in Michigan for 8 years but never heard of that. It looks like stupid idea, I cannot imagine what the advantage is supposed to be. How is it better to make a U-turn than to just make the left turn in the first place?

In New Jersey they address the left-turn issue with jug handles, which improves safety (avoids left turns across divided highways) and minimizes inconvenience.

Well if you are going straight, apparently it reduces wait times because there’s no added time for left-turning traffic. And supposedly it is easier and safer for pedestrians and cyclists to navigate turns in heavy-traffic areas.

I’m familiar with the “jug-handle” turns (and roundabouts too, which make the most sense IMHO) but I agree the Michigan Left is stupid and time-consuming; certainly for anyone who simply wants to make a left turn at an intersection.

None where I live, but they are all over in Macomb county, which tends to be high-traffic with densely-populated commercial avenues (Hello, Hall Rd) and congested to begin with.

Maybe something to that. But two weeks after the change, just when people were finally learning not to stop, the city - in all its wisdom - has changed its mind:

Stop signs to be reinstated at northeast Ann Arbor intersection

:smack::smack::smack::smack::smack::smack:

Goddamit, now it’s going to be that same old offset four-way stop, but with a shitload of extra traffic. The article mentions one nearby resident complaining that traffic on Green Road (which still had a stop sign) sometimes backed up “more than a quarter mile.” Well dude, get ready, because tonight Nixon is probably going to be backed up for a full mile.

Even more fun is in the offing. Last week we received a notice in the mail inviting public comment on a proposed 500-unit apartment/condo complex that would be built on the west side of Nixon right around Dhu Varren Road. Egads, it may be time to move soon…:frowning: