The first space ship with a self-destruct mechanism I recall was in the underappreciated Robinson Crusoe on Mars. It was not only the first, but it was unique – it was used properly. Usually they have these things at the climax of a film, so that its explosion (always a terrific , flame-spewing affair) provides the rush and enmotional oomph for the film, usually killing the bad guy or monster* and solving all the problems. But in RCoM the self-destruct was built into the ship if it became necessary to get it out of the way in case of emergency, and the hero’s blowing it up served the same purpose that the original Robinson Crusoe blowing up the ship did in Defoe’s novel – it removed it as a landmark that indicated his position and might attract the attention of pirates (or, in the case of RCoM, unwanted hostile aliens). The hero’s problem in the film was that he couldn’t get to the orbiting spaceship (he was stuck on Mars), so he had to have a remote control sswitch to blow it up, if the SF film was to parallel the 17th century novel.
Interesting to speculate that this by-now hoary cliche of science fiction might have had its origin in the desire to provide an updated version of a literary classic, and the “Destriuct” button was created as a logistical necessity because Paul Mantee’s character couldn’t climb aboard his ship and physically stow explosives.
In any event, the ship explodes far downrange, almost out of sight, far from the hero and far from the climax of the film. The ship was destroyed out of necessity, not spectacle.
Arguably the detruction of the Enterprise in Star Trek III had some of the same features – it was destroyed out of strategic necessity, and didn’t occur at the climax. It was spectacular, and did get rid of a few unneeded Klingons, though, but it was a piognant experience, unlike most of those self-destructs.
The ultimate comment on this was in the TV movie Something is Out There, where the (Earthguy) hero asks the very humanoid (Alien) heroine if she has a self-destruct mechanism on her ship (so they can blow it up and get rid of the alien monster on board).
“No,” she replies, “Why would I have something like that?” Why, indeed. How many cars, boats, or planes do we have with self-destructs on board? It’s a great fantasy for foiling would-be thieves (as in the James Bond movie For Your Eyes Only), but think of what it would do to your insurance premiums.
- Or so you think at the time. Look at Alien, though/.