World War II, of course, was a war that pitted the Americans and English and the odd picturesque Frenchman against the Germans.
Oh yeah, there was that other front. Where the Americans fought the Japanese.
WW2 began when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor.
And then stopped until D-Day, except on Guadalcanal.
Military victories or great accomplishments are only gained by disobeying orders, subordinating command, and throwing procedure out the window.
Heh heh… I see what you did there!
I forgot to mention that the Italian army, during WW II, spent most of their time in picturesque Greek villages romancing the locals.
Unless you’re Robin Hood, in which case you have an American accent. Talking of which, Robin Hood, Prince of Thieves taught me that you can land on the beaches of Dover (white cliffs) but reassure your Moorish companion that you can walk to Nottingham by nightfall (c.250 miles).
I thought it was the Germans who bombed Pearl Harbor.
Everyone from any era or place, from the poorest peasant to the wealthiest monarch, can read and write fluently. Unless it’s an important plot point for someone to be illiterate.
Most cowboys spent about 80% of their time in town, drinking, gambling, fighting and cheering the dancehall girls as they did the cancan. When they did work, it was on a ranch a half-hour ride from town.
The Trojan War, classical Greece and the first century Roman Empire were contemporary.
Anyone traveling back in time from the present day would find that the inhabitants of Britain spoke intelligable English with maybe a few thee’s and thou’s.
The horse was domesticated at about the same time dogs were, since even neolithic peoples had full-sized mounts.
In fairness to movies, TV, and bad novels, one could easily come away from an American history class (pre college level) with the same idea.
Germans?
Forget it; he’s rolling.
Though strangely the ranch was bigger than a small county. (The wormholes around The Ponderosa probably had more to do with how Ben Cartwright earned his money than the ranch; he could be in Virginia within an hour and at any number of neighbor’s ranchers even quicker if necessary, yet his ranch was so huge that you could get easily spend two or three days looking for lost cattle.)
Walnut Grove, Minnesota, was in the part of Minnesota where it only snowed once every few years (and when it did people died because they didn’t know how to handle it) and there was only one lake in walking distance.
Contrary to what was seen on Deadwood, STDs weren’t an important concern for Old West saloon girls. Can anybody really imagine Doc from Gunsmoke looking inside Miss Kitty’s girls for clap? Nope, because it didn’t happen. In fact really all they did was dance and then go upstairs to sleep, because Miss Kitty certainly wasn’t in the business of peddling pleasure.
Armor is heavy, clunky, and constantly makes metal-clanking sounds. Bad guys usually wore black armor, and also usually had their faces obscured by visors.
Kettle helms (13th century), bascinets (14th century,) sallets (15th century) and armets (16th century) were all worn at the same time.
All warhorses are enormous.
Germans usually speak to each other in English with a German accent. Despite this the most common words spoken by Germans are **Achtung! ** and **Schnell!, **closely followed by **Gott in Himmel! **Apparently the German language is almost exclusively composed of exclamations.
… crossing **Hadrian’s Wall **en route, adding several hundred more miles to their remarkable sojourn.
[QUOTE=Argent Towers]
All warhorses are enormous.
[/QUOTE]
One of my favorite scenes in both the novel and the miniseries Pillars of the Earth is when the character of Aliena, a just raped teenaged girl, and her adolescent brother mount and steal her rapist’s warhorse. For perspective, that would be roughly as realistic as saying “nice puppy” and walking away with a cop’s trained attack dog.
Right, and depicting that in a film with an accent that distinguishes his character from the others makes good sense. It doesn’t matter if the actual people in the actual time and place didn’t sound quite like that–they weren’t even speaking the same language! If we can accept English as representing Latin, I don’t see why we shouldn’t accept Spanish-accented English as representing Lusitanian-accented Latin.
And maybe the British-accented English of those other films is similar; it’s not that the characters actually speak with British accents, it’s that the actors’ British accents (among which even Americans can usually distinguish upper- from lower-class) are standing for the accents and dialects of the characters.
I would think German-accented English should work for actors depicting Nazis, though.
Also, foreigners are always incapable of learning the English words “Yes” and “No.”
I believe that in Spartacus they made a deliberate decision to give the Romans british accents and the slaves mostly american accents (Varinia (Jean Simmons), the slave exception, was explained as a tutor to her owner’s children). Somehow or other John Dall (Glabrus) and John Gavin (Julius Caesar) got in without the requisite british accents, but it seems to hold true for the rest of the leading characters Although i notice that the soldiers seem an awful american-accented lot.