A question for those who are a lawyer, those who were a lawyer, those who want to be a lawyer – or not, --and – those who just happen to know. What are the ‘up sides’ and the ‘down sides’ of a decision to pursue a formal education in the legal profession? As time and opportunity passes - I’ve grown confused over this life bending question. I’m torn . While I love the legal debate at Straightdope – I also understand (from friends) that ‘Straightdope Legal-Talk’ is atypical – and that Straightdope’s legal debate is a country mile and a hike from the work-a-day legal world. I assumed such – but is it really? If so - I wonder what that difference is? Is real legal practice all ‘will writing’ – all timely document filing – and all ‘standing by your client’ just like a lawyerly Loretta Lynn? So I ask the question - to “those” Dopers whom I have described above — how would you advise your typical undergrad who managed a damn good LSAT ----- would you tell him to follow “the plan” or would you say — “hell, fellow - follow your eastern ‘connected to the moment’ god-given ‘instincts’?”
So – what’s the general answer? – Recall – I’m not asking just for ‘me’ – so please don’t respond with “it depends on your specific circumstances.” I’m asking for “us.” So, is it -“Too many lawyers already, so stay away” – Or is it “If you’re good, a job will always be there.” – Or – “Dude, it’s all politics anyway, if you know somebody fine – if not – even better - so stay away since there are way too many lawyers.”
So – are there any general thoughts out there on the state of the profession where newbies are concerned??