Tolkien Fan Entmoot

Professor J.R.R. Tolkien squinted thoughtfully at the return address on envelope in his hand. “Gracious me!” he exclaimed, puffing reflectively at his pipe. “A letter from ‘G. Lee?’ How extraordinary that I, J.R.R. Tolkien, should recieve a message from the famous Canadian musician Geddy Lee!” Taking a silver letter opener from his writing desk, he swiftly opened the envelope, then thrust the well-tended blade with little effort deep into a wooden beam.

A single scrap of paper fluttered out, blackened on one side. “The Black Spot!” Tolkien cried out. “By thunder! 'Tis a message from the Corsair Queen of Umbar, Lean Glee Mithril! Got wind of me at last, blast her! Come away, Castamir!”

From its perch by the window, a huge macaw* flapped over to settle on his shoulder, squawking “Pennies o’ Bree! Pennies o’ Bree!”

“We’re not done for yet my lad!” Tolkien said, gathering papers into his old sea-chest. “Aye, we’ll hoist our sails, and be gone by the time they make port. We’ll do 'em yet!”

Suddenly, a pirate ship appeared on the horizon!

*The Hyacinth of Tol Earuile was indeed a bird of great splendor, and his kin who live still in latter days are but memories of his girth and majesty. Masters of dubious lore claim that these birds were descended directly from Ercanin, a Maiar of Manwe who frequently got whooped up on cheap Dorwinion liquor and then turned himself into a parrot for no damn good reason. The birds were considered sacred by the Tol Earuilian kings, and permitted to nest in the palace where their cast-off feathers were gathered and fashioned into royal robes of unsurpassed beauty, until this practice was ended during the reign of Freuling the Egregious, who decreed: ‘Too much bird poo.’ See Appendix Q, “Of Parrots.”

What if Robert Louis Stevenson wrote “Lord of the Ring” ?
Oh no! Not again!

that was great!

Ahem. It occurs to me that my last couple posts exploring the mystery of glee’s Tolkien correspondence were composed under the assumption that “glee” is a female username. Upon further consideration, I now realize that this may not in fact be the case. Speaking as an SDMB member with an ambiguous username who has experienced similar gender misattribution in the past, I apologize for any error in this regard. Perhaps glee would be more comfortable as the Pirate King of Umbar. It’s really not my place to dictate otherwise.

In my defense, I wish to point out that earlier in the thread glee confessed to “feeling like an Entwife,” which was probably the source of my confusion. And which is a perfectly appropriate feeling to have regardless of gender, I hasten to add. I think we all have our Entwife moments at one time or another in our lives. Sometimes I feel like a bipedal dog, humbly serving a rich dinner to honored guests in the house of Beorn.

I just want to know what was in the letter.

I don’t know what to say except that you consistently crack me up. Thank you.

I am delighted to hear it. My personal influence in life is otherwise uniformly neutral to negative, so any actual positive affirmation is a indescribably wonderful respite. Pardon me while I psychically vampirize your approval into a dried husk. Indeed, I may simply explode like rapidly depressurized benthic fauna. No heroic measures, please.

Also, let me assure you: decades after you become the most popular novelist of the century, and the topic of your works come up in conversation, I’ll definitely take every opportunity to describe your response to my communication in detail; and not simply mention in passing that we once exchanged remarks, without actually bothering to explain the substance of said exchange. I certainly wouldn’t just leave people hanging like that.

Well, isn’t this a rather hasty moot?

And I seem to have been left off the lists. I have a copy of the line of the Kings of Gondor and Arnor on my hard drive.

Ah, well. I really am mostly a fan of the original five books, and have not read extensively in the others. (Oh, and the short stories as well.) I vote against sending money back in time. It would change the good Professor’s association with linguistics, and without that, the whole realm of men, elves, and dwarves would not be the same, even if they existed at all. Seven languages, and a people and history for each. That’s attention to detail! And of course a land for each to live in, and an origin for each, well, it goes on and on.

It seems I am most drawn to the trees. Telperion, Laurlin, Nimloth, the ages of vast forest that stretched out over the world. No one really cares about the trees anymore. I forget who said that.

The movies were a joy, but they were not joyful because they were the same as the books. Movies are different. But some of the spirit of Middle Earth came through. They made more chain mail for that movie than the Knights Templar had! Did you see the blades they made? Viggo carried Anduril around town for weeks, to get used to it? I got yer Flame of the West, right here, pal! They all fell in love with their horses, and took them home with them.

My favorite characters were Sam, in the books, and Smeagol/Gollum in the movies. (Although Aragorn was pretty good, too.)

The Ride of Théoden, and the Rohirrim to Gondor is probably my favorite part of any book I have ever read. “Ride now! Ride now! Ride to Gondor!”

Tris

Better late then never, besides I think we are still mostly in the roll call.

As to the trees, I am pretty sure your quote is close to something Fangorn himself. Though I think Lorax is the other possibility. :wink:

But where are you keeping your copy of the lines of Finwë, Olwë, and Elwë? Or your list of all the names of the 7 houses of the Dwarves? :smiley:

Quite so. I remember a passing reference in the official LOTR magazine at the time of the first movie (late 2001) that all nine actors who’d played the members of the Fellowship got tattoos of the Elvish number “9”… even Sir Ian!

John Rhys-Davies did not get the tatoo; he sent in his stunt double to receive one instead. Really.

So, a tribute to The Beatles?

I know.

Well, my name has been invoked, so I feel a responsibility to comment. What Exit? made it very easy for me though, so I can just quote his second or third post without having to peruse every post.

This is me. The story, and the shear size of the world Tolkien created leaves me in awe. You want to know my dirty secret? I thought the LOTR books were boring and the story was told in a broken style. Not bad by any means, just not my stuff. What I enjoy greatly though was earmarking and flipping back and forth in between the appendixes. Going from written history, to maps, and then family lineages. That stuff was just so enveloped and cool.

I am watching the RotK extended edition and I just saw the lighting of the signal fires for the first time. That scene was amazing and powerful. I don’t know why it touched me so much but it did.

Jim

Signal fire! Of course! It all makes sense now; glee never specified that Tolkien responded by letter! It must have been by signal fire. Or possibly by flaming steward?

knock knock

“Who is it?”

“Gondorgram.”

“At this hour? Of all the…” (opens door)

*“AAAAAIIIIUUUUGGGGHHHHHHH!” * cracklecracklecrackle

Bulette?

Have you tried PM’ing or Emailing **glee ** yet?

GEEEEEEK!

Sorry, would you prefer this link?

On the big screen, this is one of my favorite scenes, period. I think it’s majestic.

Eh. Same-same. :smiley:

Just remember that while my Geek-screaming finger was pointing at you, three were pointing back to me. After all, I recognized the original (D&D) reference before I clicked the link.

Whew, I was worried that it might be too oblique a reference.

Um… no… I guess that would make more sense, wouldn’t it? But what fun would that be?

Anyway, I have faith that glee will reply in good time. It’s an entmoot, innit? Hasn’t it just started?

C.S. Lewis had never seen his friend in a worse state. Having boldly dropped by unannounced, he was shocked to find Tolkien looking haggard and unkempt, sitting listlessly in his study surrounded by sacks and boxes of closely-written manuscript.

“It all started with that wretched letter,” Tolkien said drearily by way of explanation. “This glee person wrote me to offer a proposal… whoever they are, they’ve taken the few bits of Entish from my books and woven it into a consistent grammar. They wanted me to–” he shuddered briefly-- “collaborate with them on a dictionary of the complete Entish language.”

“But… good heavens, Tollers; why go along with it?” Lewis exclaimed, gazing at the uncountable reams of paper all around them. “Why on earth would you devote all this time and effort to such a project?”

Tolkien stared at his friend, dark circles under his haunted eyes. “You don’t understand, Jack,” he said wearily, gesturing at the piles of literature. “This is the letter.”