Like you, DDG, we recoiled at the excess, both the waste of money and of time, and the disappointment/let down. On the other hand, we also liked opening presents and the festiveness of it all.
About 15 years ago, we took control of our celebration. Here’s how our customized fix works: Each person gets one “real” gift (gameboy, new outfit, toaster, whatever), which they participate in choosing. We wrap it up, but it’s not really a surprise.
All the rest, the surprises, have to be practical. By practical we mean “things we are always running out of.” Zip loc bags, light bulbs, batteries, scouring pads, paper towels, bandaids, vacuum cleaner bags, toothbrushes, toothpaste, shower scrubbies, canned olives, pop tarts. It’s all very silly and very fun. Especially if everyone enters into the spirit of the thing:
*Oh, Mom, you shouldn’t have!!! Not AA batteries for me!!! How did you know. Oh honey, and they’re 100 watt bulbs too, real GE Soft-White ones. Baby! A six-pack of Miller Genuine Draft, how did you know? *
The pile of presents looks great. We only spend money we were going to spend anyway. We have a great time coming up with fun, practical stuff. And, besides, it’s an excuse to buy the cool designer Star Wars bandaids and try 5 different brands of paper towels. Christmas afternoon can be spent by industrious 8 year olds in determining (through diligent use of colored water) whether Bounty really is the quicker picker upper. I’ll picker-upper you if that red food coloring gets on the carpet. Oh, mom, it’ll wash out.
Try it, you’ll like it. (By the way, my kids are now 23, 14 and 9. The oldest one participated in the “transition,” the younger two think this is “normal.”)
Oh, and since this is the pit, I HATE IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE.