Individually, I don’t get scummy vibes from either Dead Cat or Prof P, but when I look at them at the same time, I get a strong feeling that one is scum. The needle is on the Dead Cat side of the meter.
Plumpudding is a particularly in-your-face accuser. He doesn’t hold anything back and can be fairly aggressive about it. Then again, he was town, so I can’t say it’s a wolf tell but rather a confrontation style. To be fair, you’re diet Plumpudding, which is a horrible desert, but may be townie.