Trouble in Paradise (Mafia Game Thread)

OK, now you’re just pissing me off. Your post 783 does contain some reasonable points, but then at the end you simply re-state your complaint that my case against Biotop was weak. I have already acknowledged that and I changed my mind accordingly. If the fact I did so so swiftly persuades Biotop and snf to vote against me, then I have made a bad mistake and I apologise in advance to town if this causes us to lose. But the fact I placed a swift vote on Biotop and a swift switch to you should not indicate that either of these were my final decision. Look at your many votes early in the game where you did the same.

Since my initial two votes, I have come back with some deeper analysis as I promised, which you have basically ignored. In particular, you have not attempted to make a case against Biotop. I assume that’s because you think you have more chance of persuading Biotop to vote for me than vice versa, in turn because there are more potentially scummy things you can point to about my play than his. But the fact you haven’t even tried just reads scummy to me.

In your post 784 you make some reasonable points, but you don’t give any solutions.

In post 785, it is ridiculous to accuse me of a ‘blind spot in my analysis’ because I did not point out something that could point to a scum case against me. Firstly, as a town player at this critical stage of the game, why should I draw attention to something that may help me lose the game? And secondly, I haven’t been analysing my own posts or those against me because I already know my own position.

Then in 786 you again re-state a complaint you had made previously, which again I have already addressed. It should be abundantly clear that I am voting for you because I think you are the most likely final wolf. As I have also explained, I was quite happy to throw a bit of mud at the beginning of toDay to see what stuck. Given there seems to be little evidence to vote for you or Biotop, yes I am keen to ensure one of you was lynched as long as it isn’t me, which is a guaranteed mislynch from my perspective. I appreciate that unfortunately, that looks the same to an outsider as a wolf just going for a random mislynch. But I think you haven’t really backed this up with much other evidence, nor convincingly rebutted some of the evidence that points to me as town.

I don’t know why you are not even attempting to consider (apparently) the possibility that Biotop might be the wolf. If you are town, you should be, because if you can come up with a decent argument to that effect I could yet be persuaded to change my mind again. At the moment you seem to be pinning your hopes on Biotop and/or snf voting for me. Clearly, it’s hard for me to see otherwise, but it appears they don’t think you’ve made your case yet.