David Bowie and Bing Crosby singing “Little Drummer Boy” (and successfully pulling it off) is a classic, but did you know that Styx recorded an abbreviated version of the “Hallelujah Chorus”?
No, I did not know that. (Although I’m not sure it counts as an unexpected Christmas song.) Domo arigato.
Joni Mitchell, “I Wish I Had A River”, strictly speaking not a Christmas song, but at least once every year, in the lead up to Christmas, I find myself wishing I had a river to just skate away on. Y’know, instead of another rushed trip to the mall.
Bob Dylan’s Christmas album was certainly unexpected when it turned up!
Outstanding song, outstanding post.
mmm
This is somewhat different than the OP was thinking of, but I’ve always felt that Eric Johnson’s Cliffs of Dover sounds like a Christmas song.
I heard this song while walking at the mall a few days ago. I never realized what a wonderful singer Chrissie Hynde is until I heard it.
And as for Styx, the “Hallelujah Chorus” ends one side of the album. THIS ends the other one; it was a #1 request on the “Dr. Demento Show” for many years. It truly must be heard to be believed. May be NSFW.