The United States Navy is still the very best in the world, but because of decisions that have been made over the last 30 years, it simply can’t do this anymore. Full stop.
You can’t squeeze blood from a turnip.
Just imagine that you are in charge of distribution for a supermarket chain in New York City. You have your warehouse in Queens ( I’m not from there so I have no fucking idea if that’s realistic or not) so you have a fleet of trucks to handle deliveries to the store. Because you aren’t stupid, you know how many trucks you normally need, and add some more for busy days and breakdowns.
Then, for whatever reason, you have to move the warehouses to California. I know this isn’t realistic, but stay with me.
You simply don’t have enough trucks anymore. It doesn’t matter how good you are at logistics. It doesn’t matter if you have the best geniuses working on scheduling. Now the trucks have to go thousands of miles instead of tens of miles. Where one truck could make multiple trips in a day, it’s going to be gone for a couple of weeks just on one run.
You won’t be able to sell milk, ice cream or other perishables and frozen foods anymore.
The decisions were made to no longer have enough ships to supply fleets anywhere in the world. Rather, we built bases close to where we anticipated trouble and calculated the number of supply ships that would work with that model.
But the enemy gets a say, and the forward bases were attacked and essentially knocked out as logistics hubs.
Apparently, the closest base now is Diego Garcia, 2,200 nm away instead of just over a hundred. We had a comfortable number of ships if we could use the forward bases, but not enough now.
We can’t magically build more ships, so the situation is SOL.
There are people in the Pentagon, who understood that this mission was going to be really difficult if it lasted more than (however long).
Trump and Hegseth are not going to listen to reason, so even if the admirals told them the truth, it would get ignored.
Probably every administration and congress from the 90s is responsible in some degree for the basic problem.
What makes this a clusterfuck is that other administrations didn’t start wars with Iran, and they would have listened to the experts.