Only if your video card sucks. My GeForce3 Ti200 (down to $60 now) plays the game flawlessly in high resolution.
I found many of the later missions in GTA3 to be more challenging than Vice City. In fact, I still haven’t beaten GTA3. Also, while I haven’t actually counted, it seemed like GTA3 had more missions overall than Vice City. I may be wrong about that, but it’s the impression I got.
One game that often gets overlooked in threads like this is Mafia. It’s similar to the GTA games, but it’s more plot driven and not quite as open-ended. It’s built on the GTA engine, so the controls are very accurate and familiar.
It takes place in the 1930s, so you get to steal and drive all kinds of funky old cars (some of which have trouble getting past 40 MPH). Oh, and that’s another good thing. Unlike GTA, the cars actually have speedometers.
The cops in Mafia are much more strict, too. They’ll pull you over for speeding and running red lights. If this happens and you don’t have a weapon in your hand when you get out of the car to greet the cop, he’ll just give you a ticket and send you on your way.
Another great feature is that if you kill a couple of cops on an otherwise deserted street, the rest of the police force doesn’t magically realize that fact and come after you like they do in GTA.
And then there’s the graphics! Mafia is breathtaking. It really puts the GTA games to shame. From the scenery to the expressions and details on the characters’ faces, it really is a work of art. Due to this, my video card lags ever so slightly at certain points. It doesn’t happen too often, though, and I don’t exactly have a top-of-the-line card.
You can also tell that a decent bit of work went into Mafia’s plot. I mean, it’s not The Godfather or anything, but it definitely kept me quite interested - much moreso than what passes for plotlines in the GTA games.
The atmosphere of the game is amazing, too. Details, details, details! Soft (but not annoying) '30s music plays in the cars. The designs of the buildings and businesses seem very accurate for the time (at least to this non-architect). When I turn off the lights and play, it’s a wonderfully immersive experience. It’s truly one of the best games I’ve ever played.
Sorry for the Mafia hijack. I didn’t mean for it to be that long, but geez, I could go off on the wonders of that game for hours.