Reading about the horror show that was the Italian front in WWII and the hellish fighting that the ‘D-Day Dodgers’ went through, at Anzio and Monte Cassino among other places.
But what if all of it had been avoided? What if Il Duce had more foresight rather than trying to cash out by jumping in what he thought was the winning side in a short conflict, playing vulture to Germany’s lion and France’s fallen gazelle?
So let’s say that one night in early 1940 while Mussolini is pondering Italian entry in the war he is visited by Darth Vader from the planet Vulcan who shows him an incredibly vivid dream of things to come if war comes to Italy, dragged out of a car on a backroad, put against a villa wall and riddled with submachine gun fire then strung up upside down, as is tradition for infamous hangings, from a half-built gas station in Milan before having his remains mutilated and spat on.
After changing his drawers Mussolini instantly commits Italy to strict neutrality at all costs. What are the effects on the wider war? Obviously the Italians have it a lot better, with no war raging up the Italian peninsula and no bombs dropped on their heads, no sons sent to their deaths.
Another obvious massive change - no North African campaign, no reason to fight through Italian Libya. The effects of this I think would be enormous for the British, who after Dunkirk as Churchill knew there was no chance of engaging Germany in France. Without North Africa providing a fair opportunity of engaging the Axis and walking away victorious, where do they fight? Perhaps Churchill steps up the Norway raids, but they were a bit of a debacle as it was so I don’t know there would be much chance of turning the tide there, likewise it suffers from the big problem in invading the continent - no landing craft.
Another theatre favoured by Churchill was the Balkans, so maybe the British put up a better fight in Greece with no desert to fight in. Problem is it would be a lot easier for the Germans to take care of logistic problems than it would be to ship men and materiel across the Med. It would also free the Germans of the obligation of propping up their faltering Allies, so they have the 10th and 14th Armies to deploy somewhere else, not to mention one of their most capable generals, Kesselring.
But that’s just me spitballing, please correct me if I’m wrong on what we could expect the impact to be on the war if Italy did what Spain did - wisely waited the whole mess out?