I only watched a few episodes myself, and you’re right: not all of them are particularly objectionable. OTOH from what people are saying in reviews, I haven’t seen the worst of it either. But here are three time markers you can go right to, and if you think it’s okay for 4-8 year old kids to watch this kind of thing, let’s just say that I wouldn’t nominate you for Parent of the Year. It certainly seems like the kind of thing parents are trying to avoid when they set parental controls!
Episode 1.18, at the 8:54 mark (this was what I happened to see which raised alarm bells). Oh look: it’s the severed head of beloved cartoon character Mickey Mouse! And not “detached, but still talking like nothing is wrong”. Severed, as in dead: X’s in the eyes, and tongue lolling out.
From there, I worked backward to see what other potentially objectionable content she had seen. 1.4 is a humdinger. From 5:10-5:35, a first-person crowbar is used to whale away on some cute cartoon animals, and at the end of that stretch there is a horror movie-style jump scare. From 6:26-6:50, the crowbar has been exchanged for a machine gun, and multiple cute critters are dispatched (including one that they keep riddling with bullets even after it’s just a corpse bouncing around, and the dad does a little dance about this). At the end of that sequence the players are killed by one of the cute animals, and a “YOU’RE DEAD” appears on the screen in a sort of “Halloween” font. 7:15-8:00 serves up lots of gross skeleton-zombie creatures (which when injured drag themselves along the floor toward the screen), a jump scare, lots more machine-gunning, and at the end a closeup of the skull and gross bones of one of them.
Then there’s 1.3, “Dad Captured”, from 11:44 to, say, 14:25. There’s some twisted, freaky shit in this sequence of the player being captured and made ready to sacrifice to some sort of demon lord. Plus some freaky black creatures swarming at the camera and so on. And that serial killer guy with the tattered mask? Bravo to whomever designed that look: gave me shivers.
Now, keep in mind that I bought my brother-in-law a copy of “Redneck Rampage” when he was in high school. And I wouldn’t care if my high-school-aged older kids watched these videos, or even when they were a few years younger. But 7 is too young, and the kid IN the video is younger yet! Not cool.
I mean, I Googled this game (known as BATIM for short), and the general consensus seems to be that it should be restricted to 13+. Even on Reddit and other gamer boards, the most I saw was a couple people arguing that maybe you could go down to age ten depending on the kid.