[QUOTE=Shagnasty]
Almost by definition, he wasn’t following the rules of hunter and gun safety because he shot someone. Gun safety rules will aways prevent someone from be shot unintentionally if they are followed. If an accident does happen, 100% of the blame and responsibility lies with the shooter.
[/QUOTE]
Not true.
There’s certain safety measures you have to take when you’re hunting.
You should never shoot in the direction of another person, you should never shoot at “movement” but only at a clear target.
But there are definitely cases where you can shoot someone and you can be completely faultless.
I often hunt in the mountains and hills of the western counties of Virginia.
Say I’m on one side of a hollow, I see a deer in the middle of the hollow and there’s another hunter on the other side. Do I take a shot at the deer? No way, even if it’s very unlikely I hit that guy, you don’t shoot even in the general direction of another person.
However, change the situation so that everything is the same except the other hunter isn’t wearing blaze oragen, he’s wearing complete camo and is laying immobile. I can’t see him, I have no idea he’s there. I take a shot at the deer and miss, the bullet hits the other hunter.
He’d be at fault there, because legally you’re required to wear X amount of blaze orange when you hunt in Virginia. But trust me lots of hunters don’t follow that rule. That’s why I’d never shoot at “movement” it could be anything. But if I can’t even sense or see that there’s someone out there because they have themselves covered completely and are laying immobile, and I hit that person incidental to actually shooting at an animal (it could even hit the animal and go through it depending on caliber) I’m certainly not the one who is being the unsafe hunter.
What if, however, I shot at the deer and missed, hitting a hunter who was wearing blaze orange? Would that be my fault? Definitely. But it’s still possible if you’re not paying good attention that you wouldn’t notice the person in blaze orange, it happens if you’re too focused on the deer in your sights. That situation is more akin to what Cheney did. Cheney wasn’t watching his entire field of vision very well, he wasn’t paying attention and made a mistake.
For what it’s worth Cheney has dismissed all the explanations about Whittington possibly being at fault and accepted full responsibility himself. So it’s basically a moot point now.