whether or not this country was great depends largely on who you are/were and where you lived. I think when people say “Make America Great Again,” they’re talking about either one of two periods of this country’s history:
- the decade immediately following the end of WWII, or
- The early 1980s (it’s no coincidence that “Let’s Make America Great Again” was one of Reagan’s slogans for the 1980 election.)
The boom we experienced post WWII was as much good fortune as anything else. We came out of the war relatively unscathed; we hadn’t had our infrastructure bombed to smithereens, we had a ton of returning servicemen who would need jobs, and we had a ton of factories waiting to employ them (kicking out the women who worked there during the war.) Plus there was pent-up demand for manufactured goods like cars which had stopped production in favor of making military hardware. So you could get a decent paying job on an assembly line, buy a house, and start a family.
But that didn’t last long; we headed into a recession in 1953, and a much worse one in 1958. And the legendary US auto industry was already starting its slow collapse. Nash and Hudson had to merge (to form AMC) in 1954, Packard went bust in 1958 leaving a crumbling assembly plant which still sits today at Mt. Elliot and Concord in Detroit. I drive past it twice a day. Willys-Overland stopped building cars in 1955, and by 1970 sold the Jeep operation to AMC. Studebaker would go Tango Uniform in 1967. And nobody wants to admit that the Interstate highways we take for granted today were part of a huge public works project (OMG Socialism!!!) kicked off by Eisenhower.
then we started out on the first of our many ill-fated proxy wars against the Soviet Union.
but, the problem is that there are too many people who think re-runs of Leave it to Beaver are documentaries of 1950s America and insist we “go back to that.” Too bad it was never like that. people complained about Roseanne because it dared to depict a family which wasn’t distilled perfection, yet they refused to admit no family is perfect. the middle class has never lived in a lily-white neighborhood where every household is mom (who does housework in her best dress and pearls,) dad (who walks in in suit & tie saying “Hi honey, I’m home”) and their 2-3 little rascals (who are always "golly gee whiz, dad was real sore on account of I forgot to take the trash out last night.)
and let’s not forget that while a lot of people know about the Detroit riots of 1967, there was also one in 1943.
as for the 1980s, a big part of that was a natural recovery from recessions and the two energy crises of the 1970s. Were we great then? I don’t know. We were busy ceding a lot of our industry to the Japanese; I remember about the time when Sony bought Columbia Pictures, Time Magazine had on their cover an ominous “JAPAN, INC.” graphic. They were busy kicking our auto industry in the ass, they were busy kicking our electronics industry in the ass, etc.
Were we ever great? maybe, back in the 1780s when we codified rights* that few other countries did. But the rest of the world has caught up.
- yes, I know those only applied to white men, but I’m keeping it in the context of 18th century Europe.