We’ll soon start running Google text ads on the SDMB

In our ceaseless but so far futile effort to make a buck off the Straight Dope Message Board, or at least not lose our shirts, Google “AdSense” text ads will soon start appearing on SDMB message-thread pages. Some answers to what we anticipate will be FAQs:

What will the ads look like, and exactly where will they appear?

They’ll look like text, as one might suppose, consisting of a few words of promotional copy plus a hyperlink. Typically three or four ads will appear across the bottom of each thread, right above the reply box. We’re told that this is the optimal location, since you’ve finished the thread and are now deciding what to do next. We’re banking on the possibility that your eye will light on a Google ad and you’ll think, “Gosh, maybe I do need a new bulk e-mail list!” and click away. Theoretically the ads will bear some relation to the thread you just read, so you’ll find them of interest.

Some of the ads don’t seem relevant to the threads

We know. We’re curious to see how this works out. When threads are new or have only a few posts, Google doesn’t have much to go on and serves up generic ads. Threads with more history get ads that are more pertinent, although this is not a precise business. In a thread about why photographers ask people to “say cheese,” for example, some of the ads are from folks trying to sell you cheese.

How do you get paid for these ads?

It depends on the deal Google has with the advertiser. Sometimes we get paid per page view. More often we get paid each time someone clicks on a link.

I know! I’ll organize the Teeming Millions to click on every ad! You’ll make millions!

Please don’t do this. Google has been known to blacklist sites that fraudulently run up the numbers. That said, we encourage you to click on any ad you find interesting.

But you promised we wouldn’t see ads once the board went to paid subscriptions!

Hush now, we did not. We’ve always run ads. If these things were any less intrusive they’d be subliminal.

If you make money on ads, will service improve?

As always, we make no promises. However, our server contract is up for renewal, and prices have been falling. We anticipate some adjustments. For now we’ll say no more.

I saw some of these here when Jerry was testing them. They’re plenty unobtrusive. Can’t really see these Google Ads being an issue.

Don’t we these things base themselves on searching after terms used? We discuss some pretty strange things here. Next thing you know, we are going to see ads for personal lubricant, calamari recipes, photography equipment, and engineering tools.

You say that like it’s a bad thing…

I suppose it could be worse. At least they’re not huge and flashing.

Fine. But one single pop-up and I’m gone.

Those are not strange by themselves, but the thing here is that they would all be at the end of the same thread.

As long as they continue to blend in as well as they do now, I have no complaints against them, although it will probably take me a bit before they stop taking me by surprise. (Of course, being UNDER the quick reply box would be even better in my book, but I suppose there’s no chance of that :wink: )

Shhh, don’t give them ideas they are jut down there, and might be listening.
V
|
|
V

Likewise.

Would it be possible to move the ads under the post reply button? As they are now. they’re intensely ugly. Not intrusive, so much, just ugly as sin.

I have a strange urge for popcorn now.

So these ads place themselves automatically, I take it?

The three ads I see right now are for Buying Mailing Lists.

quote = “20% Off ! 16 Million Experian B2B Leads.”

Great…

Of course there’s currently one in some MPSIMS thread (forgot to note which) that says “HELP KATRINA HURRICANE RELIEF” in very big, very bold, very black letters.

Hopefully that’s a rarity, because that is annoying.

Here I am, reading a post about the new Google ads… And what is the ad on the bottom when I’m reading this? “Area Code Targeted Leads” “Opt-In Email Marketing” “Mailing Lists” “Mailing Lists at Hoover’s”. It looks like Ed wasn’t kidding when he talked about the mass market email lists :slight_smile:

Hmm. My Adblock already seems configured to prevent the display of Google ads, which is nice, since it turns out we actually pay cash money for the site. Charging and showing ads? Seriously, weak.

I was wondering about them. They just sort of snuck in, in a “huh, how long have those been there?” way.

My question is: how long until we start seeing “weird thread / ad combo” posts along the same lines as the perennial “sequential title” threads? I mean, right now the ones I"m looking are “Area Code Targeted Leads”, “Opt-in Email marketing”, “Opt in email” and “Mailing lists”, so Ed’s bulk email comment seems eerily prescient. Or google went off of the “bulk email list” keywords.

Hate’em. I guess, I don’t hate’em that much, if they mean we can stay without paying LOTS more money for subscriptions. still hate’em, though.

They don’t bother me in the least. I use Firefox and Adblock. All I see is a peaceful blank line.