What a wonderfully interesting and informative thread - thanks Carol…
I’ve no experience in the area, and the the question has been answered so…
My demon spawn is in the first year of a masters - if there is a (public) presentation component to her final project/thesis I would be very enthusiastic about attending (should she want me there)
There’s a number of people that have compared it to being present at a job interview - I’m not seeing that. A thesis is esssentially “research” right? With the findings/conclusions becoming part of “knowlege” - why wouldn’t this be publicly presented, defended and open to whoever wanted to attend? Even if they are only watching, it seems “right” (logical?) to me that the public should be there.
If a parent, partner, or supporter wanted to see this part, that seems 100% appropriate to me -
Now that it’s been mentioned, I would expect that there is some sort of “general public” accessible presentation of the research findings expected as part of the research conducted - even if the research was proprietary, there should be a way of presenting that excludes the IP portion.
In my department the thesis proposal is where the committee needs to bring up problems, and potentially where all of your ideas could get tossed out. Failure to execute what was proposed is a valid reason to fail the final defense, but then why is the defense even happening? If a committee member has issues with the methods, the time to bring that up is at the proposal, not the final.
When my daughter-in-law got defended her Virology PhD at UW Madison, her immediate family and mine both flew halfway across the country to be there for it, and it seemed like that was pretty common at that school - there were a lot of folks in the audience.
Having us all in bright red t-shirts with “Yay, Dr. S***!” and DEE-(fence image) was probably not normal, but we had fun all getting together for the first time since the wedding.
She is the first in her family to have an advanced degree, and I helped edit her application essays, so we all felt a little involved in the achievement and it was good to celebrate.
Ah, that takes me back over 40 years to my masters thesis (called a Policy Analysis Exercise or PAE at my institution). There was no defense; we were graded strictly on the paper we submitted.
I got an A, so that was great. But I was provided the committee’s written comments afterward, and one committee member said something along the lines of, “to be honest, I thought this was a terrible topic for a PAE and did not expect it to be any good. However, reading it completely changed my mind and now I see the relevance of the subject and feel the author provided an excellent analysis.” That kinda pissed me off, actually … I’m glad I was able to change his mind, but … really?
@bengangmo , congrats to your demon spawn, may she thrive in her chosen discipline!
I did an oral exam as part of my Master’s. It wasn’t really a defense. It was more like a qualification exam but only one subject (instead of three) and you pretty much always passed. I went to undergrad and grad school at the same place so I was very friendly with the Admins by that point. They told me that in all of their years only two people failed a Master’s oral. One was so nervous that he couldn’t speak so they had him calm down and come back later. The other was an arrogant smart ass so they made him wait a week and come back later.
When I first started reading this thread, I was surprised that someone said it was like helicopter parenting and comparing attendance at this event to accompanying your adult child to a job interview.
I thought it was more like attending the senior recital of your child who majored in opera or piano or something.
Reading further, I decided it was best to 1. check with the honoree, and 2. scope out the culture of the university/department.
But all in all, I agree with this:
The student is not applying for a job, they are “performing” their knowledge. It’s an exercise in exposition. If the degree is truly in jeopardy such that the defense is likely to be a humiliating defeat, then they probably wouldn’t be doing it at this time.
It’s a public performance. In my experience, it’s common for friends and family to attend the public part of presenting the thesis. I’ve attended at least half a dozen, maybe a dozen thesis defenses. I went to one a couple of weeks ago – a biology PhD candidate i met at my nephew’s wedding. I think her parents were there, also tons of friends and most of the department. (I counted nearly 100 people in the room.)
Yes, there’s a private bit at the end where the panel of professors grills the student. The more distant friends, like me, wander off, and the closer friends wait until the professors announce a newly minted PhD, and then often have a little party.
I’m surprised by the people who say their thesis defenses were private. I’ve seen them at 3 universities and several departments. So i guess local customs vary. But if the guest of honor invites you, it’s fine to attend.
It sounds OK to me, unless parents start booing and hissing tough questions, or toss in softball ones of their own (and applaud successful answers). Waving placards and banners should also be off-limits.
Please note that when I used the term “helicopter parenting”, I was not referring to what goes on when parents go to a public presentation of their child’s thesis. I was referring to certain supposedly humorous YouTube videos I’ve read or listened to. They give examples (I don’t know if they’re real) of cases where parents show up at things like job interviews and think that they can listen in and make comments. This is clearly going to get them thrown out. In the cases discussed in this thread, parents and other people can come and listen to the Ph.D. candidate talk about their subject. I wasn’t aware that there are such things (and I spent seven years in grad school). In the cases discussed here, there is both a public presentation and a private evaluation session.
That was the case with my son (PhD in biochemistry). There was a public defense in the morning. In addition to us, there were a few graduate students who weren’t as far along the trail, a couple of undergraduates who just wanted to know what the experience was like, one favorite professor who was there to wish him well, and his advisor.
My wife and I, of course, barely understood what he was studying, much less the findings he presented, so we just sat in the back and smiled at him. There were a few questions from the assembly, which he answered easily.
That was the morning session. After lunch he met with the committee in a closed door session and they formally accepted his findings. After that they officially accepted his paper for publication and as far as he was concerned that was the official moment he became a PhD. We insisted he walk at commencement anyway. We’d be damned if we didn’t get a photo of him in his regalia.
Many of those videos that talk about the stupid things that people do come from channels like Oops-Aww. There are several other such channels like them. I don’t remember any of their names at the moment.
In the several thesis committees I’ve been on, these closed door sessions as equally celebratory as the public ones, with a wee bit of teasing. Each time it’s gone:
Committee asks enough truly hard questions to see the student sweat/worry.
Advisor asks the student to step outside, in serious tones.
As soon as the door closes, Advisor grins at the committee and says “any doubters?” and we all say nope.
“So how long do we make the student sweat?” We just chat about sports or whatever for 10-15 minutes.
The advisor opens the door, and (if it’s a PhD) gives the good news with “please come back in, Doctor [name].”
I attended a friend’s math thesis defense, and after throwing him out, they called him back in. And he was there for a while. Finally, one of the panel popped out to tell the slightly anxious friends, "don’t worry, professor X is just teaching Y how to properly form German letters. (Like the ornate capital letters that represent the real or natural numbers.)