This is the only correct answer. You will not be improving his result so Stay Away. Take him out to dinner afterwards. This is an event for him, not for you. Kind of bizarre, in my personal opinion that this is even a question.
I chaired PhD defenses for a number of years and the presentation was open to the public. Usually only fellow students attended, mostly to see what it was like. And yes, spouses and parents sometimes came. After the student’s presentation was finish, all guests were removed from the room and the deliberations began. No one ever failed, at least in my experience.
You actually read the thread and still feel that way?
Out of curiosity, what is your specific personal experience with graduate school in the hard sciences?
Likewise, my master’s thesis presentation/defense was public and a large-ish number of people attended, including my parents (that evening my parents and I had dinner at my advisor’s house with his family - a great time).
That’s the way Asimov describes his experience as the sweating student (though they gave him a hint by asking him a question about a fictional chemical he had written about in a mock-scientific article in Astounding, and he knew them well-enough that they wouldn’t have asked him a question like that if there was a chance he wouldn’t make it)
I will chime in with:
It varies by school and discipline. The atmosphere can be that of a rigorous exam or of a celebratory formality.
If the rules and culture permit it, it’s not weird at all for parents to attend.
I have attended three defenses. At one of them there were about 20 people watching. The other two just a handful. I know people who defended without anyone except the candidate and three professors (is it alway three?)
I do not have a PhD and neither does Mrs Mouse. But we are in social circles where we are the only non PhDs in the room or at the table.
Wait, thiotimoline (the name of which I instantly recalled) is fictional?! ![]()
No. I had 4. I just saw a defense announcement the other day that had a half dozen.
In my field, three is pretty common, with more added sometimes as content or methods experts. My defense was attended by two of my classmates. My school was too far from where I was living for any family to attend. As my classmates and I left the exam room, one of the faculty members said to the other two, “I’ll go grab the sparkling cider,” which was certainly a clue that I need not worry about their decision.
If your child were a professional athlete or musician, would you stay away from their games or performances? After all, those events are for them, not you.
Sorry
Yes, and I think you knew the answer before you even posted this thread.
Huh? No, i assumed you read just the first post and replied, without reading any of the many posts explaining that in many departments, it’s common for friends and families to show up at the PhD defense. And i would guess that’s how everyone else took your post, too. If you actually read the thread, I’m really curious why you still feel that way.
Very late to the party, but chiming in anyway.
It’s definitely common in US physics departments and you should for sure feel free to attend since your son is encouraging it.
But, I do internally always find it a little weird, if I’m honest.
(What follows in a polemic from one professor’s perspective.)
The idea that it should be public for the sake of open academic discourse I am very much for, but that’s not why Meemaw showed up.
The idea that it is celebratory I also appreciate, but celebration can happen after the academic exercise concludes and shouldn’t interfere unduly with it.
The fact that a defense is happening does mean that “pass” is all but guaranteed, but there is real work happening during the examination. Subtle points to iron out. Results characterizations to recast. Motivations to expand on.
Treating it as a performance to a general audience weakens the goals of the defense. Sure, the committee has read the written material ahead of time (assuming the student distributed the complete thesis to the committee well enough in advance; this is not always the case, and arguably is usually not the case). But the text and iterations on it do not eliminate the value of the direct discussion. When a defense is treated like a performance (like a recital), the student naturally spends time and mental focus in the defense on general-audience material at the expense of technical details. The committee wants to wrangle with technical details – that’s why we’re meeting in person right now! Spending 20 minutes on background material or giving softball side bars throughout the presentation adds friction to the academic goals.
The advisor knows the student’s material inside and out and has concluded that things are in good shape, but other committee members are outside or semi-outside of the work, as is the “public” (other researchers) who could raise insightful points themselves. Examiners may want to press ‘pause’ often to dig into something more deeply. The entire purpose of the exercise is to get that last outside “devil’s advocate” pushback. If it’s a “performance”, that natural flow of discourse gets constricted. Shunting such discussion to a later closed session (and after everyone is feeling practical time pressures after an hour has passed already) is not a terrific replacement.
Annnnnnnyway…
In my department, sometimes the defense committee chair will choose to split the defense into public and private sessions or sometimes it will be just one public session. Sometimes there are just a handful of peers or group members in the audience, and other times the defense gets relocated to a larger venue to accommodate the dozens of friends and family that showed up.
I just roll with it. But I also don’t pull any punches! ![]()
Possibly of interest: in the UK, this is always done in closed session with just the student and the examiners. UK academics that come to the US find it especially odd when Mum’s in the room!
I expessed an opinion in the In My Humble Opinion section. I am not aware that I am required to change my opinion to the ones of other posters.
Do you have any personal experience with graduate level academia in the sciences?
Jumping over most of the other posts, my doctoral defense (also physics) was open. My relatives were all away, so the audience was just other grad students. When the committee conferred, it was just them. This was at a state university in ‘88.
As has been stated many times above, institutions vary.
In my case it’s just as well my family wasn’t there. I got rattled early on, and slogged through the rest. It was awful. They passed me anyway.
I cannot imagine anything more horrifying than my parents attending my defense. Other than committee members, the Dean’s rep, and perhaps some outside academics it would not have been allowed when I got my doctorate. Of course that was well nigh a century ago- times change. Maybe.