I believe that if a thread isn’t too long (this one isn’t), while you of course aren’t required to change your opinion because of what other people say, you ARE at least requested, as a courtesy and promoter of intelligent and civil discourse, to consider what knowledgeable posters have to offer about their perspectives and experiences before you add your own comments.
YMMV and apparently does. But it would be interesting to know: did you indeed read the thread? What rebuttals can you offer to specific comments people made that were contrary to your own blanket and harsh assessment?
Keep in mind, I ask this as someone who pretty much agreed with you when I posted the OP, but was open-minded enough to take other opinions on board. I now feel very comfortable attending the defense, and I’m grateful for the thoughtful, informed responses people have provided.
I’ll add to that that all of the other commenters added their actual experience. Either they attended graduate school, had an offspring who did or for a different reason attended someone’s thesis defense. Of course everyone is entitled to an opinion but it’s helpful to know if they are coming from a place of experience or ignorance.
There are only two reasons I can think of to fail a defense. The first is a totally incompetent adviser, and the second is in a department rife with politics, where one of the members of the committee hate the adviser.
When my wife got her masters one of the members of her committee had it in for her adviser, and told her to do more research - no chance since she had already left. The solution was that the asshole was going on sabbatical so they had another one, no changes, and she got it.
I didn’t have to do one for my masters, but I kind of did for my bachelor’s thesis, not that anyone cared very much and no one I ever heard of failed.