I wanted to add a gentle warning to the OP because I knew that we had a poster here who HATES when the word “soundtrack” is used for what is properly called a “cast recording” (“soundtrack” is for movies), then I thought I might as well do a search and remind myself of which poster I was remembering.
Looks like it was Annie-Xmas:
Anyway, I really like the soundtrack to the 90s revival of Damn Yankees and the soundtrack to the 90s revival of Chicago because both feature Bebe Neuwirth.
The 1982 recording of the cast of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat is one of my all time favorite Broadway soundtracks.