Shortly after laughing myself to death and resurrecting, I ran across my own Stupid Book Line. It hails from the ST:TNG book* Boogeymen: “Wesley didn’t feel like such a gazebo if Picard also seemed to be afraid to touch anything.”
Let’s make a trend of this. What are your favorite stupid line that you’ve run across in your reading?
Yes, I realize I was letting myself in for some stupid writing in a TNG novel. What can I say, I’m on vacation and it’s brain candy.
It’s from a ST:TNG book I read once kinda by accident: An away team meets up with some inhabitants of a mysterious space station. The inhabitants happen to be the remnants of the crew of a starship that had gone missing soome thirty years previously. Paraphrase:
Douglas Adams - The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy
It’s not particularly insightful, nor does it hold a great load of meaning. But it is so absurd and out of left field that it gives me the Rampaging Giggles. Even better in context.
There was a book called “Term Limits” by Vince Flynn that I had the…experience of reading, once. (It wasn’t Plan 9 bad, and it was fun enough, but it wasn’t really a “classic,” by a long shot, either) At one point, when trying to narrow down a list of suspects in a string of assassinations, from eyewitness descriptions and the killers’ modus operandi, they figure their suspect is a current or former member (likely the latter) of the U.S. special forces, who happens to be black.
So they decide to focus their investigation on, quote, “former black commandos.” I think they even repeat that a couple of times.
So, apparently, they’re looking for someone who used to be a black guy, but gave it up when he left the service. Quite a trick.
I never could figure out if that was an editing oversight, or if the author was being really clever and including ungrammatical dialogue on purpose, to add a vérité feel. (Then I couldn’t decide if I was rationalizing, or just being overly kind.)
Thog’s Masterclass (still an ongoing feature of Dave Langford’s Ansible SF newsletter) deserves mention in this context …
Outside of Thog, I’ve never forgotten the guy in the “Doctor Who New Adventures” novel The Bodysnatchers who “stood out like a diamond on a plate of kippers”.
Vladimir Harkonnen in House Atreides, one of the rank Dune prequels: “You nervous coward!” I wouldn’t have thought it possible for three words to be simultaneously a tautology and an oxymoron, but the writers somehow managed it.