I guess that after all the advance work that previous posters have done on my behalf I should check in at this thread. (Thanks guys for your votes of confidence, esp Billdo who posted the link to that now-famous NYC sightseeing thread.)
My advice to all NYC tourists who have a few days to spend sightseeing is to get the heck out of Manhattan for at least one day. There are four other boroughs, and though they are not as turbo-charged as Manhattan they all have their charms and attractions that make them worth a visit. (See the linked thread for some examples. If you want more – as well as lesser-known sights in Manhattan, too – get a book called City Secrets: New York City; I contributed many of my suggestions to that book.)
Since you’ll be visiting during the holidays you’ll have a rare opportunity to catch an outer-borough attraction that will pop your eyes out: the Christmas light decoration orgies of Dyker Heights, Brooklyn (83 & 84 Sts. from 10th to 13th Aves., and nearby). The residents of this neighborhood festoon their houses with garish lights, decorations and automatons that makes one think of a Caligulan Disneyland designer with lots of money and hardly any taste. Too much is never enough with these people. Some call it jubulant and delightful; others call it tacky beyond words. Whatever the case, everyone should experience it at least once in their lives.
These houses have become such a tradition that tour companies have buses that will shuttle you from Manhattan. Too easy and antiseptic! I say forego that route and take the subway – you’ll have to hike a bit, but you’ll get a real flavor for a genuine Brooklyn Italian-American neighborhood that you’ll never know from the inside of a tour bus. Plus the streets are a snap to navigate on foot. It’s a grid with numbered avenues that run N-S, and streets that run E-W – just like Manhattan except that the street numbers get higher as you walk south, not north. (Bring a map anyway since there are a few obstructions that can confound you if you don’t know the exact lay of the land.)
But why do just the Christmas light houses? Piggyback the trip with brief detours to nearby Verrazano Bridge and maybe even Fort Hamilton (they have, or had, a small military museum – better call to check). Take the R train to 95th Street & 4th Ave. (the end of the line) walk south (the street numbers will get higher) over the Belt Parkway overpass to the esplanade that runs under the Verrazano Bridge – a stunning sight and the location of some of the most memerable scenes from Saturday Night Fever. Visit Ft. Hamilton if you like which is right nearby (never been there, so I can’t offer any concrete details, sorry).
Then retrace your steps heading north along 4th Ave. to 86th Street. Turn right. Walk to 10th Ave., and turn left to 83rd Street. Turn right for the Christmas light houses. Plan your trip to get there after sunset for the most striking experience.
You’ve walked enough for a well deserved meal. Head back to 4th and 5th Aves. and check out the eateries and pastry shops there for some of the best Italian food this side of the Atlantic Ocean. Ask the locals for the best places.
Then get back on the R train (stops are at 95th, 86th and 77th Streets and 4th Ave.) to Manhattan.
Have fun!!!
~ stuyguy (who grew up only a short distance from this neighborhood)