My mom’s an administrative assistant to a school district’s superintendent. She started off with the district 20 years ago as a “lunch lady” - she had no office skills and no college degree.
How did she become a good secretary? She has the ability to learn. If she’s told “I need you to take this printed document and retype it in Word, and make it look exactly the same” she’ll figure it out. Either by admitting she doesn’t know and asking, and then PAYING ATTENTION or knowing where to seek out answers (books, help files, online, etc.)
I’m always amazed when my mom calls me up and asks me an Access question. Not because I think she’s stupid that she doesn’t know the answer - more like I’m amazed she uses Access in the first place, and she’s gotten to the point where even I have to search for the answer. I’ve shown her how to do things in Office apps since she’s become an officeworker…and I’ve only ever shown her things once. I totally admire her for that.
Seems like some of the secretaries you guys are mentioning that are bad at their jobs have some sort of mental block about the importance of retaining information, or knowing what they need to know. Secretarial jobs can really run a wide gamut of responsibilities - the good ones are the ones who can handle anything that’s thrown at them. And they are the ones who are humble enough to know when to say “I don’t know.”