What did Johnny play to beat the Devil?

“I told you once, you son-of-a-bitch, I’m the best that’s ever been.”

Johnny may have won the contest, but the Devil got him in the end on a Pride rap. :smiley:

No, the devils bit is best. But if we imagine that Johnny is playing bits from other songs we don’t even hear, then it makes sense that Johnny wins.

I disagree.

While some supernatural beings seem to possess some musical talents (angels are known to be proficient harp players, fairies can generally produce a pretty good falsetto) not so with your ordinary band of demons.

Anyway Judge Lane never mentioned any of that in the pre-fight instructions.

Really? I suppose that’s open to interpretation but there was certainly nothing in the ground rules that specifically stated certain inferior genres of music would be grounds for automatic dismissal from the contest.

And I would have liked to have seen Daniels include that one in snappy lyric form.

I’m pretty sure Johnny says that line.

DUH! It’s because he was in a bind and he was way behind and he was willing to make a deal.

WAG: It means that the title is one that has “floated” among different songs.

*E.g., * Folk Music Index - Gra to Gre
and see,

http://www.ibiblio.org/fiddlers/GRA_GRAPE.htm

I don’t recall the song well enough to judge whether the Devil or Johnny won, but I do think they’d both be bested by just about any real bluegrass fiddler imaginable - it sounds like they had to work to get the fiddle parts to sound that bad.

Pride is a sin, thereby resulting in Johnny spending eternity in The Hot Place.

Which is why Johnny lost his soul. Overweening Pride is one of the Seven Deadlies, remember? :smiley:

No, you’re not.

Fair enough. Still, if the excerpt is the best of what Johnny played, I’d demand a recount.

I don’t know if you can watch it if you’re not a subscriber, but I just watched the music video (a live by the band performance) on Yahoo Music. Do a search on videos.

The song ends with the son-of-a-bitch line, so I’m not sure if the devil would’ve gotten Johnny’s soul or not in the end.

Helloooo…your so-called “ordinary” band of demons is the only explanation for disco. A loving and merciful creator would never have thrust that upon us. Demons, I tell you, demons.
On as serious a note as I can muster, doesn’t Johnny obviously win because the lyrics go something like “the devil laid the golden fiddle on the ground at Johnny’s feet because he knew that he’d been beat.” The Devil, prideful as he is in legend, wouldn’t readily admit defeat, I wouldn’t reckon. Further, greedy as he is, I don’t think he’d easily part with a gin-u-wine Golden Fiddle unless he’d lost. Actually, deal or no deal, I think if he’d lost, he’d just have vaporized Johnny and sent him on to his eternal reward, not even giving him the chance to say the oh so awesome son-of-a-bitch line. Then again, I might be overthinking this. :smiley:

We know Johnny wins, but the Devil’s solo is obviously better. :smiley: