What do you guys think about these comedians?
As it often is with comedians and comedic actors, you either like them or you hate them, how does everyone feel about the following?
What do I think? I think, great, another chance to spread my worthless opinion on the internet! Wheeeeee!
I was going to split the list into comedians and comic actors, and then realized most are hybrid.
Richard Pryor
Gene Wilder seems to make him an actor. In other movies, he doesn’t really pull it off. A brilliant stand-up. Note to Marley23, industry gossip is that he basically wrote Blazing Saddles. Ditto Michael Keaton and Night Shift and Mister Mom. It’s too bad he was always making stupid movies to pay the stupid mistakes he made as a drug addict.
John Cleese
What the heck happened? He started selling these corporate development tapes. They’re not funny and, these days, neither is he.
George Carlin
Never struck me as more than a stoner. Was eager to hear some of his early work and be proved wrong, but it was all very on weed in the Berkshires. Don’t get it. Just don’t get it. He’s a fairly handsome man, though. Not at all bad-looking for a comic.
Jim Carrey
Agree with RealityChuck that his biggest strength is light comedy, although he was terrific in “In Living Color” sketch comedy. He’s also a strong writer, which should count for something. As far I know, his standup was mostly impressions and one-man sketches rather than jokes and monologues.
Mike Myers
One of the funniest comedic actors and sketch comics ever. Some complain that he never had the sophistication of Bill Murray (and by sophistication, I mean irony) which doesn’t seem germane. That’s not what he does. He’s warm and charming and silly and specializes in characters we can empathize with.
Robin Williams
Never, ever got his standup. Thought it was cheap and derivative (and by that I mean stolen.) Enjoyed the first half of his film career but am liking him less and less as he tries to be serious.
Bill Murray
He can do no wrong. A god-like being. He is also one of the few celebrities whose private life interests me. Do you think he is a good father and husband? Or does he leave the 400 children and their raising entirely to his traditional Catholic wife? Did I say no wrong? Of course. The Razor’s Edge never happened. Never!
Eddie Murphy
A cheap hack for a long time, using good looks and technique to get by. “Raw” is so lame. I have no idea what changed him, but by the time of Metro and Nutty Professor, Murphy was a complex and gifted comedic actor. It’s sort of horrible that by the time “Hollywood” realized that Eddie Murphy movies made gazillions of dollars, and were ready to spend umpty-billion on marketing and open wide, the movie that benefits is Daddy Daycare.
Chris Rock
Sadly, I don’t think he has what it takes as a comedic actor - I only buy him in movies and sketches cuz I love him. He is, however, a great standup and a great writer. Not sure what to make of criticisms in black press. I never saw him as selling out to the white man, even with the “when I look over my shoulder at the ATM” bit.