Hmm. Feels like this is a bit about The Great American Novel?
I would likely pick The Great Gatsby. I love the writing and the themes he writes about.
I might’ve picked To Kill a Mockingbird, and while I still love it, I feel it is a bit too “white savior”-y as I read about Atticus nobly defending the condemned Tom Robinson.
I also love The Broom of the System by David Foster Wallace. I found it on a new release bookshelf at a library and loved it, only to see DFW emerge as a leading voice in writing up to his death.
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court, by Mark Twain.
I know that his Huckleberry Finn is supposed to be The Great American Novel (and justly so), but I don’t love it. I’ve only read it twice. But I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve been through Twain’s King Arthur novel. I would love to se them do a proper screen adaptation of it – something they haven’t come close to doing yet.
Several of his other books – Life on the Mississpii. The Innocents Abroad – are also favorites of mine, but they’re not novels, so they don’t qualify for this thread.
I intentionally did not use the word ‘greatest’ in the OP, just looking for your personal favorite. They certainly could be the same title, of course.
mmm
Double Indemnity, James M. Cain. Much more bizarre than the Billy Wilder film version, which was also great, but less weird than the novel. I like weird.
Speaking of weird, The Cook by Harry Kressing. I came across this largely forgotten short 1965 novel two years ago, and I LOVE IT. Re-read it twice since.
The Natural, not the feel-good Robert Redford film version (sorry if that spoils it for anyone). The optimism, corporate greed, little man thinking he can beat the system, all make it a truly American story.