[QUOTE=Hostile Dialect]
You have succeeded in finally putting words to the unease I had with Episode 3, and with the entire series to a lesser extent. I think you nailed it: he simply doesn’t understand how humans, as social animals, work. And if you think about it, Episode 6 and to a lesser extent Episode 5 were studies in near-cathartic ill will of all kinds: Solo’s disgusting chauvinism, Lando’s cowardly revenge (hiding behind Vader’s coercion), the ease with which everyone but Solo and Artoo gives up on Skywalker on Hoth, etc. The incest revelation almost feels like Lucas giving into the temptation to destroy something beautiful. And yep, it’s definitely one of the biggest scams in history–it’s hard to believe that the world is so captivated by a series of oversimplified good-and-evil stories that stinks worse and worse with every movie, with awful dialogue and shitty character development all the way through.
[/QUOTE]
I’m glad somebody else sees it that way. Surprise, surprise, I don’t usually get much agreement (and of course, my sister, my husband, and my best friend all ADORE the movies. Sometimes I wonder how we could have such fundamentally different views of the world…).
I was reminded of Something’s Gotta Give. I watched this movie because I usually like Jack Nicholson doing his Jack-Nicholson impression. I love Diane Keaton. I sincerely love Keanu Reeves. The trailers looked funny. So how bad could it be?
Bad. Bad, bad, bad. I have many, many problems with it. But the biggest is that Jack Nicholson is a self-absorbed, piece of shit, mean, sonofabitch, jerk. And he’s that way in every movie, but unlike all of his other movies, his foil is Keanu Reeves. A charming, sweet, adoring, kind, loving, handsome, smart, doctor Keanu Reeves.
And I’m supposed to believe that she would choose Jack fucking Nicholson over Keanu Reeves? And further, that her choice constitutes a happy ending?
Fuck you, Nancy Meyers!