It’s sad to say, but there really hasn’t been a new, truly iconic superhero for God knows how long. I don’t collect comics as fanatically as I used to, and only rarely stop in at Forbidden Planet to peruse what’s on sale. Still, I’ve noticed that there has been no true sensation title to compare to, say, the X-Men when I was a mere teen in the early 1980s. I see lots and lots of new titles, most featuring re-workings of long established characters, but nothing that seems really fresh and different.
It got me to thinking what qualities a new character must have right off the bat, from issue #1, in order to break away from the pack of generic folks in spandex, and establish himself as a comic book superstar? (e.g., Why did Spider-Man become a popular bit of modern folklore, while the Blue Beetle become an also-ran?)
-
Obviously, he must be powerful, and have a varied assortment of superpowers. (If a team of heroes, they usually have one specific power apiece, but a solo hero has to possess a range of abilities. Using the same single power over and over again would be instantly monotonous.) These powers must have a general motif, and can’t be just a random scattering of abilities
-
A flashy costume. Something flashy and colorful, but not an eyesore. This is easier said than done, given that as tastes in fashions in the real world change, some costumes tend to look more dated than others. (cough *Legion of Super-Heroes *cough) A truly iconic hero may have their costumes slightly tweaked as the times change, (Wonder Woman lopping the high heels on her boots, and ditching the ear-rings, for example), but has to remain relatively constant.
-
A compelling theme. Batman is a dark knight avenger, so driven to avenge his parents murders that he has transformed himself into something not quite human. Spider-Man is a nerdy shnook who just can’t get a break no matter how hard he tries. The JLA are superheroes so super, they appear godlike to normal people, while the X-Men are freakish oddballs. The stories can’t just be foiling the bad guys latest fiendish plot, they must deal with an idea that resonates with readers.
-
A coherent backstory. Heroes, of course, plummet in popularity as their established histories become murkier. The “Spider-clone” storyline of the 90’s being the archetypal disaster scenario. It’s doubtful that we’ll see any clones showing up in future Spider-man sequels.
-
Interesting / likeable supporting characters. Where would Batman be without Robin and Alfred? Would Spider-Man really have been such a success without Aunt May and J. Jonah Jameson to contend with, as well as Dr. Octopus? Methinks not.
-
Truly menacing opponents. Especially, an arch-nemesis that is the antithesis of everything the hero stands for. Batman is a law & order zealot, the Joker is anarchy incarnate. Superman is the apex of physical perfection, Lex Luthor is the craftiest, shrewdest player of mindgames ever. Reed Richards is rational, and dedicated to scientific exploration with selfless motivations of the greatest good for all humanity, Dr. Doom uses technology to advance his own utterly narcissistic goals.
-
A base of operations. The Batcave, Xavier’s school, Avenger’s Mansion, the Fortress of Solitude, Paradise Island. (the New York City of Marvel Comics is uniquely Spider-Man’s domain.)
Anything else I forget?