[QUOTE=elelle]
I’m Buddhist, and was not at all offended by the OP.
[/QUOTE]
If you had been offended, could you still be Buddhist? 
Interesting question. Basically “When did you realize that some things just frigging suck and there’s no rhyme nor reason to it?” I suppose.
I’m tempted to recall this time when I was spraying tar on a road and just as we were ready to go this snot nosed little kid’s dog ran up and got his footprints in the tar an… nah, I’ll go with another.
I grew up on a farm with a lot of elderly relatives and a bipolar mother so there was always some animal or person dying or getting wished dead so I’m not sure when it would have happened. I remember- the full story is too gross to go into- but a puppy we had who developed what I can only describe as a “flesh eating virus” when he was only about 3 or 4 weeks old and his being abandoned by his mother and siblings; it started with a hole the size of a quarter and within a day it was rotting alive on almost an entire side and it was clear there was no way he could live and that he was absolutely miserable and we had an old “horse doctor” (i.e. non-formally educated vet) who worked for us sometimes give it a lethal injection to end its misery. That bothered me a lot but I can’t say I found it anything more profound than sad and gross.
So I’ll move up a lot later than the ones above when I was 15. My father had died two weeks before, very suddenly (heart attack) and we were still reeling from the shock of the death. My father had identical twin aunts, Kitty & Carrie (I’m the boy in the middle*, the twins are to my left), who were much more like twin grandmothers to us than great-aunts; they lived on our farm in the cabin where they were born and they slept in the bed where they were born for 93 years. They were both innate Zen-masters (though they could be ornery, but I don’t think either of them ever had ill-will for another person or desire for anything beyond general contentment) and true to form they even looked like Yoda.
Two weeks after my father died one of the twins, the “prettier” and “feistier” of the two, lit her gas heater as she’d done for godknowshowmany years and caught the hem of her dress ablaze. When it was over she had 3rd degree burns over 90% of her body, no lips, no ears or eyelids or facial features of any kind, her upper dentures were melted into the roof of her mouth, and she was still alive. Her twin witnessed all of this, her twin flagged down an car (they had no phone and could not have used it if they had) to get her help- struck paydirt as the first car was a deputy with a CB- and her sister was taken in a helicopter (first time airborne of course) to the burn tank in B’ham many miles away (Birmingham has one of the best burn treatment units in the world) but it was hopeless. We were told that a 21 year old in perfect physical condition would have had a 50/50 chance of surviving the night and a 10% chance of surviving 2 days, and 93 year old Kitty survived for more than a week.
I saw her in the hospital even though my mother tried to physically restrain me from entering. I wish she’d been able to because it’s of course imprinted forever on my brain- not sure what was grosser- the charred black skin or the bits that still looked like Kitty just somehow for no apparent reason still there like islands amidst them. Gross. But the thing that really hit me was that until this I’d always been taught to believe God had a plan, He was merciful, it didn’t make sense to us but it did to Him, etc., and I sat in the pasture a few days later while my mother was still in B’ham and I was avoiding a gaggle of crazy cousins telling Carrie (Kitty’s twin) “The Lord’s gonna heal her and she’s gonna be just fine” and other crazy shit, and I thought to myself "There is absolutely no conceivable possible way that a 93 year old woman who has never done anybody on Earth harm being burned that horribly and yet left alive to feel it can possibly be orchestrated by a loving God or that it can possibly serve any good purpose, and if any good does come out of it I can tell you here and now that I’m a 15 year old borderline D student in the sticks of Alabama and I can come up with another way of achieving that same “noble goal” that doesn’t involve this absolute nightmare. (The room in the cabin smelled of smoke, burned flesh and vomit for years- the vomit was from an EMT, that’s how bad it was.)
That was not the beginnning of my atheism but it was the end of my Christianity as most would describe the term. It was the beginning of my “life is an illusion we are in Maya” transmigration and New Age-ish “Jesus was a turned on dude but hardly the only one” neo-Mormon neo-pagan neo-Hindu neo-Buddhist phase that lasted off and on for about 10 years before I stopped adding epicycles and pericycles to the system I’d envisioned and just realized “Or not- maybe there is no God and no meaning— and in a way, I really like that better”. (If I were to say what made me an atheist it would probably be reading Mark Twain’s Captain Stormfield Goes to Heaven combined with an Occam’s Razor moment and the comfort that came from “She didn’t burn horribly because of karma or past lives and it wasn’t illusion and she did exist- she burned horribly because her hem fell into a heater that day and it was horrible, but it didn’t really mean anything and it wasn’t anything personal against her, it was just bad shit and it happened”.
Or maybe it was when *Sigmund and the Sea Monsters * was cancelled. It was totally uncalled for, and yet they let Soul Train remain on, OR when my brother ran over my beloved *KORG 70,000 BC * lunchbox. Or when my mother ran over Freckles. The third time.
*This is that same wall today, just for shits and gigles.