I’m struck by this also.
By any objective standard, I actually had a tolerable time. I hung out with the theater crowd, so I had lots of fun friends. I never really connected with the “popular” kids; unlike the situation some other people have described, the theater group at our high school was not where the popular kids congregated. No, they went to the yearbook staff, where I also was, and the school newspaper, where I had a high profile and briefly controversial role. I was asked to play one of three characters on the homecoming float, and I was voted “most likely to win the Pulitzer” in the yearbook my senior year.
Sure, I was picked on, and had difficult times with difficult people. I didn’t care much for gym; I sucked at basketball and didn’t like showering with everybody. However, I wasn’t a total klutz, and I could be athletic when I wanted. I was regularly chosen in the top half of the team for soccer, kickball, softball, and whatnot when those were the class activities. Maybe it’s because people noticed how well I did during the yearly Presidential Physical Fitness trials; I always placed highly in almost all the categories.
So consider me another popular dork. I was called a brain and a nerd most of the time, but thankfully I didn’t get a lot of flak for it, and most of the people who “mattered” actually seemed to like me, more or less. I escaped a lot of the really horrible torments suffered by so many smart and geeky kids. Perhaps it’s because there were people even geekier than I was, further down the totem pole.
In fact — and I must say, I will be eternally shameful for this — I participated in some of the teasing of the kids further down. There was one guy in particular to whom we were merciless, and who wound up shooting himself as a result. For about three seconds, we were shocked, but when it turned out he’d made what we thought at the time was a muddle of it (he shot himself in the stomach, and then went for help), we made fun of him for that. “The stupidhead can’t even kill himself right!” I feel like a complete shitheel for what we put him through, and I hope he turned out okay. There aren’t enough apologies in the world to make up for what an asshole I was to that guy.
I have no idea what happened to him, because I don’t keep in regular touch with a single person with whom I went to high school. There are a few of them around, and we’re cordial when we occasionally run into each other (and there are a couple I should probably make a point of contacting again, so I don’t lose them), but my circle of friends in those years has nothing to do with my circle of friends now. College folks made a much bigger impression on my life.