As a card carryin’ Pagan Priestess[sup]TM[/sup], I actually am faced with this decision IRL. (Sometimes I wish we had a big book to tell me what to do when I don’t feel like planning anything, but I digress.)
My favorites? Fruits dipped into chocolate sauce and hand-fed to one another, along with sparkling herb-infused champagne. (Hello, Beltaine!)
Chocolate’s always very popular. There’s even a whole chocolate ritual that you can find online, with the different elements represented by different forms of chocolate, and the eucharist hot cocoa and Hershey’s bars.
Not so popular are the rice cakes and flat Pepsi that show up when some dolt forgot to bring the eucharist.
Actually, a church I once attended, unknowingly had the wine replaced with vinegar by an alcoholic deacon. After that, the priest would whiff the wine before communion.