What's Benedict Cumberbatch's Best Performance?

I got around to watching Dr. Strange last night (mainly because he’ll be in Infinity War) and it was okay. Not great but not a waste of time. I wasn’t really impressed with Cumberbatch though and his attempts at humor felt flat although that could have just been the script.

Only other place I’ve seen Cumberbatch was the first season of Sherlock which my wife insisted I watch. I felt that Martin Freeman was more interesting, both the character of Watson and Freeman’s performance.

However, I know that Cumberbatch is a Big Thing and he’s trained in theater and all that so perhaps I just haven’t seen him in the right stuff – likely enough since I don’t watch a lot of stuff. And I haven’t exactly followed his career. So, if I wanted to make the case that an ailing Cumberbatch deserved a kidney from the SAG Spare Organs Vault, what would I use as evidence?

Mainly all I know is that he’s a famous actor, I guess some women find him dreamy and the tired “B[whatever] C[whatever]” name joke thing.

He was very effective as Martin Crieff in Cabin Pressure, although that may not impress the SAG folks. He seems to play cocky, arrogant types quite often, but Martin is very shy and unsure of himself. If it weren’t for Cumberbatch’s name in the credits, I’d have never known it was him.

I was going to say the same thing. He does do cocky and arrogant well, though - his turn as Richard III in The Hollow Crown was excellent.

His National Theater Live performance as Hamlet was outstanding.

Knights and swords and Dame Judi Dench. I can give that a try.

BBC Radio programs might be trickier. I see his National Theater Live performance will be in select theaters in the Chicago area in March although I’d probably try watching The Hollow Crown in the comfort of my home before taking that plunge.

Figure the default starting point would be the one he got an Oscar nomination for?

Which was, admittedly, right in his Sherlock wheelhouse – The Genius Who Doesn’t Really Understand How Normal People Interact, But Who Can Do A Passable Job Of It When He Makes An Effort To Emulate Social Skills, Especially When He Is A Step Ahead Of You On The Subject Being Discussed, Which Isn’t Always But Is Often – only with plenty of scenes where he struggles to keep his emotions from getting the better of him.

So . . . THE IMITATION GAME, maybe?

It must not be in any of the things I’ve watched him in, IMO.

For me, Sherlock, but yes, Martin Freeman was great.

True, but of the four main cast members, I think he stands out the least.

Agreed, but it kinda works that way; plays the least stand-out character, and wouldn’t want the biggest name in the cast to overshadow the others.

I wonder if it was deliberate on his part, or a consequence of his film acting makes him a bit more restrained than the others.

Khan.

The third episode of the first season of Sherlock, which I know you watched, is his best individual performance.

I thought that was spelled: “KHHHHHHHAAAAAAANNNNNNNNNN!!!”

He was quite decent in the recent adaptation of Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, which I watched again recently. But he does get somewhat overshadowed by the rest of what was a superbly cast ensemble.

He was absolutely outstanding in “The Imitation Game,” though the movie is otherwise quite overrated, in my opinion. He delivered the goods in that one and it’s not another cocky, self-assured prick.

Awesome. My work here is done. Thanks for coming everyone, we’re locking up now :wink:

I’ll have a go at The Imitation Game as well then. Trying to keep an open positive mind here instead of “Cumberbatch Sucks, Prove Me Wrong!”

I didn’t think he sucked anyway and assume that effect-laden superhero movies probably aren’t the best test or example of one’s acting chops.

To be fair that’s pretty high praise when cast alongside acting gods like Gary Oldman and Tom Hardy.

I think that was definitely intentional. There was a scene where he makes a joke to Wong and gets no response. He mutters “People used to think I was funny.” Wong replies “Did they work for you?” The implication being that people only laughed to suck up to him, and he was too arrogant to realize he really wasn’t all that funny.

And with that out of the way… yes definitely “The Imitation Game”.

Just what I came in to post. He was great in both Henry VI, Part III and Richard III. That scene in the Henry VI movie where he comes to kill the former king at the end is bone-chilling.

I also loved The Imitation Game. His Alan Turing certainly makes Sheldon Cooper look silly.

I’m not liking him in anything where he has to play an American. His American accent is atrocious.

There are many lesser known projects he’s acted in that are worth a look…

Fortysomething was a short miniseries that also starred Hugh Laurie and Anna Chancellor.

Atonement has him playing (surprise) a totally, posh ass.

Third Star playing a terminally ill young man on a road trip

To the Ends of the Earth an historical novel adaption - also starring Charles Dance, JJ Fields, Sam Neil