In all my time lurking and posting, I have never actually seen just a plain old “What’s the best band ever?” thread. So here it is. There’s no restrictions. They can be well known or a no name band. New, old, whatever.
My vote goes to the glorious, the lovable, Pavement. They just never cease to amaze me with their greatness. Song after song is pure genius.
This depends. Do you mean who’s the greatest band at a particular time, or who was the greatest for their complete body of work?
For a band at their peak, I’d say it would be the Beatles in the mid-60s, CCR during their short run, or The Tragically Hip from about '89 to '94. There are some other good ones too… Prince and the Revolution were awfully good. REM’s “Out of Time” and “Automatic for the People” was about as good a two-album run as anyone has ever had. The Beach Boys were awesome.
But for the total body of work, it’s harder to say. U2 is building quite a resume; the Stones were great for about 20, 25 years (even though they suck now.)
My vote goes to WEEZER. I’m totally obsessed with them… got all their CD’s, posters, b-side tracks (70+songs)…all the new tracks for the new album “Maladroid”…uh…only thing I’m missing is actually seeing them live…argh!
I’d say sublime. They played everything from thrash-punk to reggae to gospel, and when they played a different style of music it actual sounded like a different style of music. They weren’t like some other bands where people go on and on about how diverse they are but it really all sounds the same. Sublime really is/was the most diverse and best sounding band I’ve ever heard in my life. Bradley Nowell had a phenomenal voice and was probably the greatest ska guitar player I’ve ever heard (and one of the best guitarists period.) I have about 25 of their albums but like 22 of them are on tape and I don’t have a tape player anymore
Down in my basement I have every record that Procol Harum ever made, saw them 6 or 7 times live back in the 60-70s. My son, who I used to rock to sleep while they played on the stereo, just gave my first CD of their music. I had forgotten how good they were. On Whaling Stories they evoke in 7 min the exact same emotional response that Beethoven took an hour to do with the Ninth. Don’t get me wrong I still love the Ninth I’m just saying is all. They may not be the best band ever, as their body of work is small, but I can’t think of any band that was more talented lyrically, or musically.
Glenn Miller Band, Count Basie, Duke Ellington, Beatles, Nelson Riddle Orchestra, Rolling Stones, The Band, and on a good night, and they had many, The Grateful Dead (also a lot of stinker nights). And many, many others.