Personally, I think he needs to look around the boards a little more.
Personally, I don’t think he needs to look around the boards any more. 
Even though you asked for ‘friendly but serious’ feedback, IMHO isn’t the place for discussing other posters. It might be Debate Light but the focus is still on ideas, not specific personalities. So this doesn’t really fly, even as a poll.
This hovers in a gray area. You specifically rejected flaming, so the Pit won’t suit. I’d just move it to MPSIMS but methinks there’s a strong context running underneath, based on cricetus rather forcefully and disdainfully dismissing IMHO as a forum.
Which is his right, btw. Making him the subject of a thread might not eve lure him into the forum, and it undoubtedly wouldn’t change his mind about the quality of discussion here. This is just a bad idea.
Closed.
TVeblen