As other people have pointed out in this thread, in the UK/Australia, it can refer to either one. So I still think my thesis that the word is more along the way towards being a tabu word in the US is correct.
I’m not sure there was ever an original tabu word that that all these euphemisms are substituting for. Or another way to put it, it’s euphemisms all the way down.
I don’t really think it is particularly taboo in the US. I think it appears that way to Brits (et al) because they use the word to refer to the room and we don’t—see the thread I linked to.
That’s mostly why it’s becoming tabu, because it only refers to the porcelain thing in the US. But note I say it’s only moving towards being tabu; it hasn’t quite reached that point yet.
Depends where you are. While in New Zealand I was surprised by the number of public restrooms and they were easy to find. Just look for the signs that say “Toilet” with an arrow pointing in the correct direction.
I imagine many Americans would say there’s something “dirty” about the sound of the word “toilet,” with its echoes of “soil” and “oil” (and even “bemoil”). Though that’s probably post-hoc rationalizing…
In Elizabethan times, “jakes” was the slang term, but monarchs had a “Groom of the Stool” to, erm, attend them. At some point “closet” came in, and later “WC”.
If memory serves, even Chaucer used a euphemism, something like ‘that place to which we all go’.
Actually “Jakes”, from “Jack’s”, is only half a step removed from our present-day “John”. The Toilet was a place every “John” or “Jack” eventually had to go.
The Elizabethans, being bawdy Elizabethans, couldn’t help making punning jokes about it. The classical hero Ajax from the Trojan War found himself involved in these as “A-Jax” = “A Jakes” = “A Toilet”
Euphemisms (which clearly go back to ancient times and before) aside, “shitter” has already been mentioned. The OED has a quote from 1386 mentioning a “schetyngpanne”.
Jaques, aka Master What-ye-call’t, is the guy from As You Like It…
That’s a ridiculous name. I feel like taking a shower, using several rolls in an attempt to dry off, and then posting a picture with wet tissue stuck all over me and several empty rolls in the background with, of course, a scathing post criticizing their crappy “bath tissue”.